When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific: Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions

Andrew R.M. Bradbury, Nathan D. Trinklein, Holger Thie, Ian C. Wilkinson, Atul K. Tandon, Stephen Anderson, Catherine L. Bladen, Brittany Jones, Shelley Force Aldred, Marco Bestagno, Oscar Burrone, Jennifer Maynard, Fortunato Ferrara, James Trimmer, Janina Görnemann, Jacob Glanville, Philipp Wolf, Andre Frenzel, Julin Wong, Xin Yu KohHui Yan Eng, David Lane, Marie Paule Lefranc, Mike Clark, Stefan Dübel

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Monoclonal antibodies are commonly assumed to be monospecific, but anecdotal studies have reported genetic diversity in antibody heavy chain and light chain genes found within individual hybridomas. As the prevalence of such diversity has never been explored, we analyzed 185 random hybridomas, in a large multicenter dataset. The hybridomas analyzed were not biased towards those with cloning difficulties or known to have additional chains. Of the hybridomas we evaluated, 126 (68.1%) contained no additional productive chains, while the remaining 59 (31.9%) contained one or more additional productive heavy or light chains. The expression of additional chains degraded properties of the antibodies, including specificity, binding signal and/or signal-to-noise ratio, as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and immunohistochemistry. The most abundant mRNA transcripts found in a hybridoma cell line did not necessarily encode the antibody chains providing the correct specificity. Consequently, when cloning antibody genes, functional validation of all possible VH and VL combinations is required to identify those with the highest affinity and lowest cross-reactivity. These findings, reflecting the current state of hybridomas used in research, reiterate the importance of using sequence-defined recombinant antibodies for research or diagnostic use.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)539-546
Number of pages8
JournalmAbs
Volume10
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - May 19 2018

Fingerprint

Hybridomas
Monoclonal Antibodies
Antibodies
Organism Cloning
Light
Antibody Specificity
Signal-To-Noise Ratio
Research
Genes
Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay
Immunohistochemistry
Cell Line
Messenger RNA

Keywords

  • hybridoma
  • monoclonal antibodies
  • paratope
  • recombinant antibodies
  • specificity

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Immunology and Allergy
  • Immunology

Cite this

Bradbury, A. R. M., Trinklein, N. D., Thie, H., Wilkinson, I. C., Tandon, A. K., Anderson, S., ... Dübel, S. (2018). When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific: Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions. mAbs, 10(4), 539-546. https://doi.org/10.1080/19420862.2018.1445456

When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific : Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions. / Bradbury, Andrew R.M.; Trinklein, Nathan D.; Thie, Holger; Wilkinson, Ian C.; Tandon, Atul K.; Anderson, Stephen; Bladen, Catherine L.; Jones, Brittany; Aldred, Shelley Force; Bestagno, Marco; Burrone, Oscar; Maynard, Jennifer; Ferrara, Fortunato; Trimmer, James; Görnemann, Janina; Glanville, Jacob; Wolf, Philipp; Frenzel, Andre; Wong, Julin; Koh, Xin Yu; Eng, Hui Yan; Lane, David; Lefranc, Marie Paule; Clark, Mike; Dübel, Stefan.

In: mAbs, Vol. 10, No. 4, 19.05.2018, p. 539-546.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bradbury, ARM, Trinklein, ND, Thie, H, Wilkinson, IC, Tandon, AK, Anderson, S, Bladen, CL, Jones, B, Aldred, SF, Bestagno, M, Burrone, O, Maynard, J, Ferrara, F, Trimmer, J, Görnemann, J, Glanville, J, Wolf, P, Frenzel, A, Wong, J, Koh, XY, Eng, HY, Lane, D, Lefranc, MP, Clark, M & Dübel, S 2018, 'When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific: Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions', mAbs, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 539-546. https://doi.org/10.1080/19420862.2018.1445456
Bradbury, Andrew R.M. ; Trinklein, Nathan D. ; Thie, Holger ; Wilkinson, Ian C. ; Tandon, Atul K. ; Anderson, Stephen ; Bladen, Catherine L. ; Jones, Brittany ; Aldred, Shelley Force ; Bestagno, Marco ; Burrone, Oscar ; Maynard, Jennifer ; Ferrara, Fortunato ; Trimmer, James ; Görnemann, Janina ; Glanville, Jacob ; Wolf, Philipp ; Frenzel, Andre ; Wong, Julin ; Koh, Xin Yu ; Eng, Hui Yan ; Lane, David ; Lefranc, Marie Paule ; Clark, Mike ; Dübel, Stefan. / When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific : Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions. In: mAbs. 2018 ; Vol. 10, No. 4. pp. 539-546.
@article{95ce112d2d844c91b5a8710d957c3066,
title = "When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific: Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions",
abstract = "Monoclonal antibodies are commonly assumed to be monospecific, but anecdotal studies have reported genetic diversity in antibody heavy chain and light chain genes found within individual hybridomas. As the prevalence of such diversity has never been explored, we analyzed 185 random hybridomas, in a large multicenter dataset. The hybridomas analyzed were not biased towards those with cloning difficulties or known to have additional chains. Of the hybridomas we evaluated, 126 (68.1{\%}) contained no additional productive chains, while the remaining 59 (31.9{\%}) contained one or more additional productive heavy or light chains. The expression of additional chains degraded properties of the antibodies, including specificity, binding signal and/or signal-to-noise ratio, as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and immunohistochemistry. The most abundant mRNA transcripts found in a hybridoma cell line did not necessarily encode the antibody chains providing the correct specificity. Consequently, when cloning antibody genes, functional validation of all possible VH and VL combinations is required to identify those with the highest affinity and lowest cross-reactivity. These findings, reflecting the current state of hybridomas used in research, reiterate the importance of using sequence-defined recombinant antibodies for research or diagnostic use.",
keywords = "hybridoma, monoclonal antibodies, paratope, recombinant antibodies, specificity",
author = "Bradbury, {Andrew R.M.} and Trinklein, {Nathan D.} and Holger Thie and Wilkinson, {Ian C.} and Tandon, {Atul K.} and Stephen Anderson and Bladen, {Catherine L.} and Brittany Jones and Aldred, {Shelley Force} and Marco Bestagno and Oscar Burrone and Jennifer Maynard and Fortunato Ferrara and James Trimmer and Janina G{\"o}rnemann and Jacob Glanville and Philipp Wolf and Andre Frenzel and Julin Wong and Koh, {Xin Yu} and Eng, {Hui Yan} and David Lane and Lefranc, {Marie Paule} and Mike Clark and Stefan D{\"u}bel",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1080/19420862.2018.1445456",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "10",
pages = "539--546",
journal = "mAbs",
issn = "1942-0862",
publisher = "Landes Bioscience",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - When monoclonal antibodies are not monospecific

T2 - Hybridomas frequently express additional functional variable regions

AU - Bradbury, Andrew R.M.

AU - Trinklein, Nathan D.

AU - Thie, Holger

AU - Wilkinson, Ian C.

AU - Tandon, Atul K.

AU - Anderson, Stephen

AU - Bladen, Catherine L.

AU - Jones, Brittany

AU - Aldred, Shelley Force

AU - Bestagno, Marco

AU - Burrone, Oscar

AU - Maynard, Jennifer

AU - Ferrara, Fortunato

AU - Trimmer, James

AU - Görnemann, Janina

AU - Glanville, Jacob

AU - Wolf, Philipp

AU - Frenzel, Andre

AU - Wong, Julin

AU - Koh, Xin Yu

AU - Eng, Hui Yan

AU - Lane, David

AU - Lefranc, Marie Paule

AU - Clark, Mike

AU - Dübel, Stefan

PY - 2018/5/19

Y1 - 2018/5/19

N2 - Monoclonal antibodies are commonly assumed to be monospecific, but anecdotal studies have reported genetic diversity in antibody heavy chain and light chain genes found within individual hybridomas. As the prevalence of such diversity has never been explored, we analyzed 185 random hybridomas, in a large multicenter dataset. The hybridomas analyzed were not biased towards those with cloning difficulties or known to have additional chains. Of the hybridomas we evaluated, 126 (68.1%) contained no additional productive chains, while the remaining 59 (31.9%) contained one or more additional productive heavy or light chains. The expression of additional chains degraded properties of the antibodies, including specificity, binding signal and/or signal-to-noise ratio, as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and immunohistochemistry. The most abundant mRNA transcripts found in a hybridoma cell line did not necessarily encode the antibody chains providing the correct specificity. Consequently, when cloning antibody genes, functional validation of all possible VH and VL combinations is required to identify those with the highest affinity and lowest cross-reactivity. These findings, reflecting the current state of hybridomas used in research, reiterate the importance of using sequence-defined recombinant antibodies for research or diagnostic use.

AB - Monoclonal antibodies are commonly assumed to be monospecific, but anecdotal studies have reported genetic diversity in antibody heavy chain and light chain genes found within individual hybridomas. As the prevalence of such diversity has never been explored, we analyzed 185 random hybridomas, in a large multicenter dataset. The hybridomas analyzed were not biased towards those with cloning difficulties or known to have additional chains. Of the hybridomas we evaluated, 126 (68.1%) contained no additional productive chains, while the remaining 59 (31.9%) contained one or more additional productive heavy or light chains. The expression of additional chains degraded properties of the antibodies, including specificity, binding signal and/or signal-to-noise ratio, as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and immunohistochemistry. The most abundant mRNA transcripts found in a hybridoma cell line did not necessarily encode the antibody chains providing the correct specificity. Consequently, when cloning antibody genes, functional validation of all possible VH and VL combinations is required to identify those with the highest affinity and lowest cross-reactivity. These findings, reflecting the current state of hybridomas used in research, reiterate the importance of using sequence-defined recombinant antibodies for research or diagnostic use.

KW - hybridoma

KW - monoclonal antibodies

KW - paratope

KW - recombinant antibodies

KW - specificity

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85044542376&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85044542376&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/19420862.2018.1445456

DO - 10.1080/19420862.2018.1445456

M3 - Article

C2 - 29485921

AN - SCOPUS:85044542376

VL - 10

SP - 539

EP - 546

JO - mAbs

JF - mAbs

SN - 1942-0862

IS - 4

ER -