Unconscious race and class bias

Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons

Adil H. Haider, Eric B. Schneider, N. Sriram, Deborah S. Dossick, Valerie K. Scott, Sandra M. Swoboda, Lia Losonczy, Elliott R. Haut, David T. Efron, Peter J. Pronovost, Julie A. Freischlag, Pamela A. Lipsett, Edward E. Cornwell, Ellen J. Mackenzie, Lisa A. Cooper

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

52 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Recent studies have found that unconscious biases may influence physicians' clinical decision making. The objective of our study was to determine, using clinical vignettes, if unconscious race and class biases exist specifically among trauma/acute care surgeons and, if so, whether those biases impact surgeons' clinical decision making. METHODS: A prospective Web-based survey was administered to active members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma. Participants completed nine clinical vignettes, each with three trauma/acute care surgery management questions. Race Implicit Association Test (IAT) and social class IAT assessments were completed by each participant. Multivariable, ordered logistic regression analysis was then used to determine whether implicit biases reflected on the IAT tests were associated with vignette responses. RESULTS: In total, 248 members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma participated. Of these, 79% explicitly stated that they had no race preferences and 55% stated they had no social class preferences. However, 73.5% of the participants had IAT scores demonstrating an unconscious preference toward white persons; 90.7% demonstrated an implicit preference toward upper social class persons. Only 2 of 27 vignette-based clinical decisions were associated with patient race or social class on univariate analyses. Multivariable analyses revealed no relationship between IAT scores and vignette-based clinical assessments. CONCLUSION: Unconscious preferences for white and upper-class persons are prevalent among trauma and acute care surgeons. In this study, these biases were not statistically significantly associated with clinical decision making. Further study of the factors that may prevent implicit biases from influencing patient management is warranted. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiologic study, level II.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)409-416
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery
Volume77
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - 2014
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Decision Making
Social Class
Wounds and Injuries
Epidemiologic Studies
Logistic Models
Regression Analysis
Unconscious (Psychology)
Surgeons
Physicians
Clinical Decision-Making

Keywords

  • disparities
  • Implicit Association Test
  • surgeon
  • Trauma
  • unconscious bias

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine
  • Surgery

Cite this

Haider, A. H., Schneider, E. B., Sriram, N., Dossick, D. S., Scott, V. K., Swoboda, S. M., ... Cooper, L. A. (2014). Unconscious race and class bias: Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons. Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, 77(3), 409-416. https://doi.org/10.1097/TA.0000000000000392

Unconscious race and class bias : Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons. / Haider, Adil H.; Schneider, Eric B.; Sriram, N.; Dossick, Deborah S.; Scott, Valerie K.; Swoboda, Sandra M.; Losonczy, Lia; Haut, Elliott R.; Efron, David T.; Pronovost, Peter J.; Freischlag, Julie A.; Lipsett, Pamela A.; Cornwell, Edward E.; Mackenzie, Ellen J.; Cooper, Lisa A.

In: Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, Vol. 77, No. 3, 2014, p. 409-416.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Haider, AH, Schneider, EB, Sriram, N, Dossick, DS, Scott, VK, Swoboda, SM, Losonczy, L, Haut, ER, Efron, DT, Pronovost, PJ, Freischlag, JA, Lipsett, PA, Cornwell, EE, Mackenzie, EJ & Cooper, LA 2014, 'Unconscious race and class bias: Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons', Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, vol. 77, no. 3, pp. 409-416. https://doi.org/10.1097/TA.0000000000000392
Haider, Adil H. ; Schneider, Eric B. ; Sriram, N. ; Dossick, Deborah S. ; Scott, Valerie K. ; Swoboda, Sandra M. ; Losonczy, Lia ; Haut, Elliott R. ; Efron, David T. ; Pronovost, Peter J. ; Freischlag, Julie A. ; Lipsett, Pamela A. ; Cornwell, Edward E. ; Mackenzie, Ellen J. ; Cooper, Lisa A. / Unconscious race and class bias : Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons. In: Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery. 2014 ; Vol. 77, No. 3. pp. 409-416.
@article{ac1d6b0bec4d400894fbd1a5827b5709,
title = "Unconscious race and class bias: Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Recent studies have found that unconscious biases may influence physicians' clinical decision making. The objective of our study was to determine, using clinical vignettes, if unconscious race and class biases exist specifically among trauma/acute care surgeons and, if so, whether those biases impact surgeons' clinical decision making. METHODS: A prospective Web-based survey was administered to active members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma. Participants completed nine clinical vignettes, each with three trauma/acute care surgery management questions. Race Implicit Association Test (IAT) and social class IAT assessments were completed by each participant. Multivariable, ordered logistic regression analysis was then used to determine whether implicit biases reflected on the IAT tests were associated with vignette responses. RESULTS: In total, 248 members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma participated. Of these, 79{\%} explicitly stated that they had no race preferences and 55{\%} stated they had no social class preferences. However, 73.5{\%} of the participants had IAT scores demonstrating an unconscious preference toward white persons; 90.7{\%} demonstrated an implicit preference toward upper social class persons. Only 2 of 27 vignette-based clinical decisions were associated with patient race or social class on univariate analyses. Multivariable analyses revealed no relationship between IAT scores and vignette-based clinical assessments. CONCLUSION: Unconscious preferences for white and upper-class persons are prevalent among trauma and acute care surgeons. In this study, these biases were not statistically significantly associated with clinical decision making. Further study of the factors that may prevent implicit biases from influencing patient management is warranted. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiologic study, level II.",
keywords = "disparities, Implicit Association Test, surgeon, Trauma, unconscious bias",
author = "Haider, {Adil H.} and Schneider, {Eric B.} and N. Sriram and Dossick, {Deborah S.} and Scott, {Valerie K.} and Swoboda, {Sandra M.} and Lia Losonczy and Haut, {Elliott R.} and Efron, {David T.} and Pronovost, {Peter J.} and Freischlag, {Julie A.} and Lipsett, {Pamela A.} and Cornwell, {Edward E.} and Mackenzie, {Ellen J.} and Cooper, {Lisa A.}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1097/TA.0000000000000392",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "77",
pages = "409--416",
journal = "Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery",
issn = "2163-0755",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Unconscious race and class bias

T2 - Its association with decision making by trauma and acute care surgeons

AU - Haider, Adil H.

AU - Schneider, Eric B.

AU - Sriram, N.

AU - Dossick, Deborah S.

AU - Scott, Valerie K.

AU - Swoboda, Sandra M.

AU - Losonczy, Lia

AU - Haut, Elliott R.

AU - Efron, David T.

AU - Pronovost, Peter J.

AU - Freischlag, Julie A.

AU - Lipsett, Pamela A.

AU - Cornwell, Edward E.

AU - Mackenzie, Ellen J.

AU - Cooper, Lisa A.

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - BACKGROUND: Recent studies have found that unconscious biases may influence physicians' clinical decision making. The objective of our study was to determine, using clinical vignettes, if unconscious race and class biases exist specifically among trauma/acute care surgeons and, if so, whether those biases impact surgeons' clinical decision making. METHODS: A prospective Web-based survey was administered to active members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma. Participants completed nine clinical vignettes, each with three trauma/acute care surgery management questions. Race Implicit Association Test (IAT) and social class IAT assessments were completed by each participant. Multivariable, ordered logistic regression analysis was then used to determine whether implicit biases reflected on the IAT tests were associated with vignette responses. RESULTS: In total, 248 members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma participated. Of these, 79% explicitly stated that they had no race preferences and 55% stated they had no social class preferences. However, 73.5% of the participants had IAT scores demonstrating an unconscious preference toward white persons; 90.7% demonstrated an implicit preference toward upper social class persons. Only 2 of 27 vignette-based clinical decisions were associated with patient race or social class on univariate analyses. Multivariable analyses revealed no relationship between IAT scores and vignette-based clinical assessments. CONCLUSION: Unconscious preferences for white and upper-class persons are prevalent among trauma and acute care surgeons. In this study, these biases were not statistically significantly associated with clinical decision making. Further study of the factors that may prevent implicit biases from influencing patient management is warranted. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiologic study, level II.

AB - BACKGROUND: Recent studies have found that unconscious biases may influence physicians' clinical decision making. The objective of our study was to determine, using clinical vignettes, if unconscious race and class biases exist specifically among trauma/acute care surgeons and, if so, whether those biases impact surgeons' clinical decision making. METHODS: A prospective Web-based survey was administered to active members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma. Participants completed nine clinical vignettes, each with three trauma/acute care surgery management questions. Race Implicit Association Test (IAT) and social class IAT assessments were completed by each participant. Multivariable, ordered logistic regression analysis was then used to determine whether implicit biases reflected on the IAT tests were associated with vignette responses. RESULTS: In total, 248 members of the Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma participated. Of these, 79% explicitly stated that they had no race preferences and 55% stated they had no social class preferences. However, 73.5% of the participants had IAT scores demonstrating an unconscious preference toward white persons; 90.7% demonstrated an implicit preference toward upper social class persons. Only 2 of 27 vignette-based clinical decisions were associated with patient race or social class on univariate analyses. Multivariable analyses revealed no relationship between IAT scores and vignette-based clinical assessments. CONCLUSION: Unconscious preferences for white and upper-class persons are prevalent among trauma and acute care surgeons. In this study, these biases were not statistically significantly associated with clinical decision making. Further study of the factors that may prevent implicit biases from influencing patient management is warranted. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiologic study, level II.

KW - disparities

KW - Implicit Association Test

KW - surgeon

KW - Trauma

KW - unconscious bias

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84907307068&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84907307068&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/TA.0000000000000392

DO - 10.1097/TA.0000000000000392

M3 - Article

VL - 77

SP - 409

EP - 416

JO - Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery

JF - Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery

SN - 2163-0755

IS - 3

ER -