The health care aide position in nursing homes: A comparative survey of nurses’ and aides’ perceptions

Leehu Zysberg, Tova Band-Winterstein, Issi Doron, Ksenya Shulyaev, Elena O Siegel, Dorota Kornas-Biela, Anna Zisberg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: The health care aide position embodies one of the most basic paradoxes of long-term care for older adults: those who have the most contact and most intensive interaction with nursing-home residents are also those having the least training, authority, and status within the system. They therefore hold one of the keys to quality care in many settings, especially nursing homes. In the absence of agreement on the position's roles, responsibilities, and authority, it is important to examine how the position is perceived by the key members in the long-term-care framework. Objectives: The current study examined and compared health care aides’ and nurses’ perceptions of the position in nursing-home settings in Israel, using a standardized tool developed for this inquiry. The comparison accounted for potential intervening factors that may help better understand the job requirements and boundaries. Design: A comparative survey design. Settings: 30 nursing homes (of at least 20 beds) in northern Israel. Participants: We used convenience sampling to recruit 369 health care aides and 261 nurses (a total of 630 participants). Methods: The main instrument of data collection was specially designed and validated for this study. It was based on a qualitative study that defined basic content units representing tasks importance, knowledge, and personal characteristics for the job. Results: Participants found it difficult to prioritize the job components or to differentiate between core tasks and characteristics and the secondary aspects of their job. General care, profession-specific knowledge, and emotional abilities were endorsed the most by participants. Cleaning, communication, and safety were ranked lower (although rankings were still considerably high). However, previous experience as a health care aide undermined incumbents’ perceptions of their own responsibilities and professionalism. Incumbent health care aides rated most factors higher than nurses did, with the exception of the importance of communication. Conclusion: Our results may help decision makers understand the complexity around the health care aide position, manage and develop it more effectively while setting standards (training and certification, performance appraisal, and more) for professionalization processes and better defining the division of nursing work between health care aides and nurses.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)98-106
Number of pages9
JournalInternational Journal of Nursing Studies
Volume94
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 1 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Nurses' Aides
Nursing Homes
Delivery of Health Care
Long-Term Care
Israel
Communication
Aptitude
Quality of Health Care
Certification
Surveys and Questionnaires
Nursing
Nurses
Safety

Keywords

  • Aged
  • Intersectoral collaboration
  • Nurses’ aides
  • Nursing
  • Nursing homes
  • Standard of care

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Nursing(all)

Cite this

The health care aide position in nursing homes : A comparative survey of nurses’ and aides’ perceptions. / Zysberg, Leehu; Band-Winterstein, Tova; Doron, Issi; Shulyaev, Ksenya; Siegel, Elena O; Kornas-Biela, Dorota; Zisberg, Anna.

In: International Journal of Nursing Studies, Vol. 94, 01.06.2019, p. 98-106.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Zysberg, Leehu ; Band-Winterstein, Tova ; Doron, Issi ; Shulyaev, Ksenya ; Siegel, Elena O ; Kornas-Biela, Dorota ; Zisberg, Anna. / The health care aide position in nursing homes : A comparative survey of nurses’ and aides’ perceptions. In: International Journal of Nursing Studies. 2019 ; Vol. 94. pp. 98-106.
@article{d23889eccd724f89a5ef09a2111903c9,
title = "The health care aide position in nursing homes: A comparative survey of nurses’ and aides’ perceptions",
abstract = "Background: The health care aide position embodies one of the most basic paradoxes of long-term care for older adults: those who have the most contact and most intensive interaction with nursing-home residents are also those having the least training, authority, and status within the system. They therefore hold one of the keys to quality care in many settings, especially nursing homes. In the absence of agreement on the position's roles, responsibilities, and authority, it is important to examine how the position is perceived by the key members in the long-term-care framework. Objectives: The current study examined and compared health care aides’ and nurses’ perceptions of the position in nursing-home settings in Israel, using a standardized tool developed for this inquiry. The comparison accounted for potential intervening factors that may help better understand the job requirements and boundaries. Design: A comparative survey design. Settings: 30 nursing homes (of at least 20 beds) in northern Israel. Participants: We used convenience sampling to recruit 369 health care aides and 261 nurses (a total of 630 participants). Methods: The main instrument of data collection was specially designed and validated for this study. It was based on a qualitative study that defined basic content units representing tasks importance, knowledge, and personal characteristics for the job. Results: Participants found it difficult to prioritize the job components or to differentiate between core tasks and characteristics and the secondary aspects of their job. General care, profession-specific knowledge, and emotional abilities were endorsed the most by participants. Cleaning, communication, and safety were ranked lower (although rankings were still considerably high). However, previous experience as a health care aide undermined incumbents’ perceptions of their own responsibilities and professionalism. Incumbent health care aides rated most factors higher than nurses did, with the exception of the importance of communication. Conclusion: Our results may help decision makers understand the complexity around the health care aide position, manage and develop it more effectively while setting standards (training and certification, performance appraisal, and more) for professionalization processes and better defining the division of nursing work between health care aides and nurses.",
keywords = "Aged, Intersectoral collaboration, Nurses’ aides, Nursing, Nursing homes, Standard of care",
author = "Leehu Zysberg and Tova Band-Winterstein and Issi Doron and Ksenya Shulyaev and Siegel, {Elena O} and Dorota Kornas-Biela and Anna Zisberg",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2019.03.007",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "94",
pages = "98--106",
journal = "International Journal of Nursing Studies",
issn = "0020-7489",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The health care aide position in nursing homes

T2 - A comparative survey of nurses’ and aides’ perceptions

AU - Zysberg, Leehu

AU - Band-Winterstein, Tova

AU - Doron, Issi

AU - Shulyaev, Ksenya

AU - Siegel, Elena O

AU - Kornas-Biela, Dorota

AU - Zisberg, Anna

PY - 2019/6/1

Y1 - 2019/6/1

N2 - Background: The health care aide position embodies one of the most basic paradoxes of long-term care for older adults: those who have the most contact and most intensive interaction with nursing-home residents are also those having the least training, authority, and status within the system. They therefore hold one of the keys to quality care in many settings, especially nursing homes. In the absence of agreement on the position's roles, responsibilities, and authority, it is important to examine how the position is perceived by the key members in the long-term-care framework. Objectives: The current study examined and compared health care aides’ and nurses’ perceptions of the position in nursing-home settings in Israel, using a standardized tool developed for this inquiry. The comparison accounted for potential intervening factors that may help better understand the job requirements and boundaries. Design: A comparative survey design. Settings: 30 nursing homes (of at least 20 beds) in northern Israel. Participants: We used convenience sampling to recruit 369 health care aides and 261 nurses (a total of 630 participants). Methods: The main instrument of data collection was specially designed and validated for this study. It was based on a qualitative study that defined basic content units representing tasks importance, knowledge, and personal characteristics for the job. Results: Participants found it difficult to prioritize the job components or to differentiate between core tasks and characteristics and the secondary aspects of their job. General care, profession-specific knowledge, and emotional abilities were endorsed the most by participants. Cleaning, communication, and safety were ranked lower (although rankings were still considerably high). However, previous experience as a health care aide undermined incumbents’ perceptions of their own responsibilities and professionalism. Incumbent health care aides rated most factors higher than nurses did, with the exception of the importance of communication. Conclusion: Our results may help decision makers understand the complexity around the health care aide position, manage and develop it more effectively while setting standards (training and certification, performance appraisal, and more) for professionalization processes and better defining the division of nursing work between health care aides and nurses.

AB - Background: The health care aide position embodies one of the most basic paradoxes of long-term care for older adults: those who have the most contact and most intensive interaction with nursing-home residents are also those having the least training, authority, and status within the system. They therefore hold one of the keys to quality care in many settings, especially nursing homes. In the absence of agreement on the position's roles, responsibilities, and authority, it is important to examine how the position is perceived by the key members in the long-term-care framework. Objectives: The current study examined and compared health care aides’ and nurses’ perceptions of the position in nursing-home settings in Israel, using a standardized tool developed for this inquiry. The comparison accounted for potential intervening factors that may help better understand the job requirements and boundaries. Design: A comparative survey design. Settings: 30 nursing homes (of at least 20 beds) in northern Israel. Participants: We used convenience sampling to recruit 369 health care aides and 261 nurses (a total of 630 participants). Methods: The main instrument of data collection was specially designed and validated for this study. It was based on a qualitative study that defined basic content units representing tasks importance, knowledge, and personal characteristics for the job. Results: Participants found it difficult to prioritize the job components or to differentiate between core tasks and characteristics and the secondary aspects of their job. General care, profession-specific knowledge, and emotional abilities were endorsed the most by participants. Cleaning, communication, and safety were ranked lower (although rankings were still considerably high). However, previous experience as a health care aide undermined incumbents’ perceptions of their own responsibilities and professionalism. Incumbent health care aides rated most factors higher than nurses did, with the exception of the importance of communication. Conclusion: Our results may help decision makers understand the complexity around the health care aide position, manage and develop it more effectively while setting standards (training and certification, performance appraisal, and more) for professionalization processes and better defining the division of nursing work between health care aides and nurses.

KW - Aged

KW - Intersectoral collaboration

KW - Nurses’ aides

KW - Nursing

KW - Nursing homes

KW - Standard of care

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85063649917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85063649917&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2019.03.007

DO - 10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2019.03.007

M3 - Article

C2 - 30951989

AN - SCOPUS:85063649917

VL - 94

SP - 98

EP - 106

JO - International Journal of Nursing Studies

JF - International Journal of Nursing Studies

SN - 0020-7489

ER -