The failure of success

cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest

Zihua Zhao, Cang Hui, Richard E. Plant, Min Su, Nikos T. Papadopoulos, Tim Carpenter, Zhihong Li, James R. Carey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In the six decades since 1960, the oriental fruit fly, Bactrocera dorsalis (Hendel), has been announced successfully eradicated in California by the U.S. Department of Agriculture a total of 564 times. This includes eradication declarations in one city a total of 25 different years, in 12 cities 8–19 different years, and in 101 cities 2–7 different years. We here show that the false negatives in declaring elimination success hinge on the easily achieved regulatory criteria, which have virtually guaranteed the failure of complete extirpation of this pest. Analyses of the time series of fly detection over California placed on a grid of 100-km2 cells revealed (1) partial success of the eradication program in controlling the invasion of the oriental fruit fly; (2) low prevalence of the initial detection in these cells is often followed by high prevalence of recurrences; (3) progressively shorter intervals between years of consecutive detections; and (4) high likelihood of early-infested cells also experiencing the most frequent outbreaks. Facing the risk of recurrent invasions, such short-term eradication programs have only succeeded annually according to the current regulatory criteria but have failed to achieve the larger goal of complete extirpation of the oriental fruit fly. Based on the components and running costs of the current programs, we further estimated the efficiency of eradication programs with different combinations of eradication radius, duration, and edge impermeability in reducing invasion recurrences and slowing the spread of the oriental fruit fly. We end with policy implications including the need for agricultural agencies worldwide to revisit eradication protocols in which monitoring and treatments are terminated when the regulatory criteria for declaring eradication are met. Our results also have direct implications to invasion biologists and agriculture policy makers regarding long-term risks of short-term expediency.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere01991
JournalEcological Applications
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

fruit
agriculture
pest
time series
programme
monitoring
cost
detection
city
policy

Keywords

  • biological invasions
  • detection
  • eradication
  • invasion ecology
  • prevalence
  • risk
  • spatial process
  • surveillance
  • tephritids

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Zhao, Z., Hui, C., Plant, R. E., Su, M., Papadopoulos, N. T., Carpenter, T., ... Carey, J. R. (Accepted/In press). The failure of success: cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest. Ecological Applications, [e01991]. https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.1991

The failure of success : cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest. / Zhao, Zihua; Hui, Cang; Plant, Richard E.; Su, Min; Papadopoulos, Nikos T.; Carpenter, Tim; Li, Zhihong; Carey, James R.

In: Ecological Applications, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Zhao, Zihua ; Hui, Cang ; Plant, Richard E. ; Su, Min ; Papadopoulos, Nikos T. ; Carpenter, Tim ; Li, Zhihong ; Carey, James R. / The failure of success : cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest. In: Ecological Applications. 2019.
@article{b4af3764b36c4646a367e288c1fe88b0,
title = "The failure of success: cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest",
abstract = "In the six decades since 1960, the oriental fruit fly, Bactrocera dorsalis (Hendel), has been announced successfully eradicated in California by the U.S. Department of Agriculture a total of 564 times. This includes eradication declarations in one city a total of 25 different years, in 12 cities 8–19 different years, and in 101 cities 2–7 different years. We here show that the false negatives in declaring elimination success hinge on the easily achieved regulatory criteria, which have virtually guaranteed the failure of complete extirpation of this pest. Analyses of the time series of fly detection over California placed on a grid of 100-km2 cells revealed (1) partial success of the eradication program in controlling the invasion of the oriental fruit fly; (2) low prevalence of the initial detection in these cells is often followed by high prevalence of recurrences; (3) progressively shorter intervals between years of consecutive detections; and (4) high likelihood of early-infested cells also experiencing the most frequent outbreaks. Facing the risk of recurrent invasions, such short-term eradication programs have only succeeded annually according to the current regulatory criteria but have failed to achieve the larger goal of complete extirpation of the oriental fruit fly. Based on the components and running costs of the current programs, we further estimated the efficiency of eradication programs with different combinations of eradication radius, duration, and edge impermeability in reducing invasion recurrences and slowing the spread of the oriental fruit fly. We end with policy implications including the need for agricultural agencies worldwide to revisit eradication protocols in which monitoring and treatments are terminated when the regulatory criteria for declaring eradication are met. Our results also have direct implications to invasion biologists and agriculture policy makers regarding long-term risks of short-term expediency.",
keywords = "biological invasions, detection, eradication, invasion ecology, prevalence, risk, spatial process, surveillance, tephritids",
author = "Zihua Zhao and Cang Hui and Plant, {Richard E.} and Min Su and Papadopoulos, {Nikos T.} and Tim Carpenter and Zhihong Li and Carey, {James R.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/eap.1991",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Ecological Applications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The failure of success

T2 - cyclic recurrences of a globally invasive pest

AU - Zhao, Zihua

AU - Hui, Cang

AU - Plant, Richard E.

AU - Su, Min

AU - Papadopoulos, Nikos T.

AU - Carpenter, Tim

AU - Li, Zhihong

AU - Carey, James R.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - In the six decades since 1960, the oriental fruit fly, Bactrocera dorsalis (Hendel), has been announced successfully eradicated in California by the U.S. Department of Agriculture a total of 564 times. This includes eradication declarations in one city a total of 25 different years, in 12 cities 8–19 different years, and in 101 cities 2–7 different years. We here show that the false negatives in declaring elimination success hinge on the easily achieved regulatory criteria, which have virtually guaranteed the failure of complete extirpation of this pest. Analyses of the time series of fly detection over California placed on a grid of 100-km2 cells revealed (1) partial success of the eradication program in controlling the invasion of the oriental fruit fly; (2) low prevalence of the initial detection in these cells is often followed by high prevalence of recurrences; (3) progressively shorter intervals between years of consecutive detections; and (4) high likelihood of early-infested cells also experiencing the most frequent outbreaks. Facing the risk of recurrent invasions, such short-term eradication programs have only succeeded annually according to the current regulatory criteria but have failed to achieve the larger goal of complete extirpation of the oriental fruit fly. Based on the components and running costs of the current programs, we further estimated the efficiency of eradication programs with different combinations of eradication radius, duration, and edge impermeability in reducing invasion recurrences and slowing the spread of the oriental fruit fly. We end with policy implications including the need for agricultural agencies worldwide to revisit eradication protocols in which monitoring and treatments are terminated when the regulatory criteria for declaring eradication are met. Our results also have direct implications to invasion biologists and agriculture policy makers regarding long-term risks of short-term expediency.

AB - In the six decades since 1960, the oriental fruit fly, Bactrocera dorsalis (Hendel), has been announced successfully eradicated in California by the U.S. Department of Agriculture a total of 564 times. This includes eradication declarations in one city a total of 25 different years, in 12 cities 8–19 different years, and in 101 cities 2–7 different years. We here show that the false negatives in declaring elimination success hinge on the easily achieved regulatory criteria, which have virtually guaranteed the failure of complete extirpation of this pest. Analyses of the time series of fly detection over California placed on a grid of 100-km2 cells revealed (1) partial success of the eradication program in controlling the invasion of the oriental fruit fly; (2) low prevalence of the initial detection in these cells is often followed by high prevalence of recurrences; (3) progressively shorter intervals between years of consecutive detections; and (4) high likelihood of early-infested cells also experiencing the most frequent outbreaks. Facing the risk of recurrent invasions, such short-term eradication programs have only succeeded annually according to the current regulatory criteria but have failed to achieve the larger goal of complete extirpation of the oriental fruit fly. Based on the components and running costs of the current programs, we further estimated the efficiency of eradication programs with different combinations of eradication radius, duration, and edge impermeability in reducing invasion recurrences and slowing the spread of the oriental fruit fly. We end with policy implications including the need for agricultural agencies worldwide to revisit eradication protocols in which monitoring and treatments are terminated when the regulatory criteria for declaring eradication are met. Our results also have direct implications to invasion biologists and agriculture policy makers regarding long-term risks of short-term expediency.

KW - biological invasions

KW - detection

KW - eradication

KW - invasion ecology

KW - prevalence

KW - risk

KW - spatial process

KW - surveillance

KW - tephritids

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85071364527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85071364527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/eap.1991

DO - 10.1002/eap.1991

M3 - Article

JO - Ecological Applications

JF - Ecological Applications

SN - 1051-0761

M1 - e01991

ER -