Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus

Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol

Marina Boccardi, Rossana Ganzola, Martina Bocchetta, Michela Pievani, Alberto Redolfi, George Bartzokis, Richard Camicioli, John G. Csernansky, Mony J. De Leon, Leyla Detoledo-Morrell, Ronald J. Killiany, Stéphane Lehéricy, Johannes Pantel, Jens C. Pruessner, H. Soininen, Craig Watson, Simon Duchesne, Clifford R. Jack, Giovanni B. Frisoni

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

93 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Manual segmentation from magnetic resonance imaging (MR) is the gold standard for evaluating hippocampal atrophy in Alzheimers disease (AD). Nonetheless, different segmentation protocols provide up to 2.5-fold volume differences. Here we surveyed the most frequently used segmentation protocols in the AD literature as a preliminary step for international harmonization. The anatomical landmarks (anteriormost and posteriormost slices, superior, inferior, medial, and lateral borders) were identified from 12 published protocols for hippocampal manual segmentation ([Abbreviation] first author, publication year: [B] Bartzokis, 1998; [C] Convit, 1997; [dTM] deToledo-Morrell, 2004; [H] Haller, 1997; [J] Jack, 1994; [K] Killiany, 1993; [L] Lehericy, 1994; [M] Malykhin, 2007; [Pa] Pantel, 2000; [Pr] Pruessner, 2000; [S] Soininen, 1994; [W] Watson, 1992). The hippocampi of one healthy control and one AD patient taken from the 1.5T MR ADNI database were segmented by a single rater according to each protocol. The accuracy of the protocols interpretation and translation into practice was checked with lead authors of protocols through individual interactive web conferences. Semantically harmonized landmarks and differences were then extracted, regarding: (a) the posteriormost slice, protocol [B] being the most restrictive, and [H, M, Pa, Pr, S] the most inclusive; (b) inclusion [C, dTM, J, L, M, Pr, W] or exclusion [B, H, K, Pa, S] of alveus/fimbria; (c) separation from the parahippocampal gyrus, [C] being the most restrictive, [B, dTM, H, J, Pa, S] the most inclusive. There were no substantial differences in the definition of the anteriormost slice. This survey will allow us to operationalize differences among protocols into tracing units, measure their impact on the repeatability and diagnostic accuracy of manual hippocampal segmentation, and finally develop a harmonized protocol.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)61-75
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Alzheimer's Disease
Volume26
Issue numberSUPPL. 3
DOIs
StatePublished - 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Hippocampus
Alzheimer Disease
Joints
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Parahippocampal Gyrus
Atrophy
Publications
Databases
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • Alzheimers disease
  • anatomical landmark
  • atrophy
  • degeneration
  • harmonization
  • Hippocampus
  • manual segmentation protocol
  • manual tracing
  • medial temporal lobes
  • MRI

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Psychiatry and Mental health
  • Geriatrics and Gerontology
  • Clinical Psychology

Cite this

Boccardi, M., Ganzola, R., Bocchetta, M., Pievani, M., Redolfi, A., Bartzokis, G., ... Frisoni, G. B. (2011). Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus: Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol. Journal of Alzheimer's Disease, 26(SUPPL. 3), 61-75. https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-2011-0004

Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus : Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol. / Boccardi, Marina; Ganzola, Rossana; Bocchetta, Martina; Pievani, Michela; Redolfi, Alberto; Bartzokis, George; Camicioli, Richard; Csernansky, John G.; De Leon, Mony J.; Detoledo-Morrell, Leyla; Killiany, Ronald J.; Lehéricy, Stéphane; Pantel, Johannes; Pruessner, Jens C.; Soininen, H.; Watson, Craig; Duchesne, Simon; Jack, Clifford R.; Frisoni, Giovanni B.

In: Journal of Alzheimer's Disease, Vol. 26, No. SUPPL. 3, 2011, p. 61-75.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Boccardi, M, Ganzola, R, Bocchetta, M, Pievani, M, Redolfi, A, Bartzokis, G, Camicioli, R, Csernansky, JG, De Leon, MJ, Detoledo-Morrell, L, Killiany, RJ, Lehéricy, S, Pantel, J, Pruessner, JC, Soininen, H, Watson, C, Duchesne, S, Jack, CR & Frisoni, GB 2011, 'Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus: Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol', Journal of Alzheimer's Disease, vol. 26, no. SUPPL. 3, pp. 61-75. https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-2011-0004
Boccardi, Marina ; Ganzola, Rossana ; Bocchetta, Martina ; Pievani, Michela ; Redolfi, Alberto ; Bartzokis, George ; Camicioli, Richard ; Csernansky, John G. ; De Leon, Mony J. ; Detoledo-Morrell, Leyla ; Killiany, Ronald J. ; Lehéricy, Stéphane ; Pantel, Johannes ; Pruessner, Jens C. ; Soininen, H. ; Watson, Craig ; Duchesne, Simon ; Jack, Clifford R. ; Frisoni, Giovanni B. / Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus : Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol. In: Journal of Alzheimer's Disease. 2011 ; Vol. 26, No. SUPPL. 3. pp. 61-75.
@article{2daf41455afe4317b5bc585a6d6b1878,
title = "Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus: Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol",
abstract = "Manual segmentation from magnetic resonance imaging (MR) is the gold standard for evaluating hippocampal atrophy in Alzheimers disease (AD). Nonetheless, different segmentation protocols provide up to 2.5-fold volume differences. Here we surveyed the most frequently used segmentation protocols in the AD literature as a preliminary step for international harmonization. The anatomical landmarks (anteriormost and posteriormost slices, superior, inferior, medial, and lateral borders) were identified from 12 published protocols for hippocampal manual segmentation ([Abbreviation] first author, publication year: [B] Bartzokis, 1998; [C] Convit, 1997; [dTM] deToledo-Morrell, 2004; [H] Haller, 1997; [J] Jack, 1994; [K] Killiany, 1993; [L] Lehericy, 1994; [M] Malykhin, 2007; [Pa] Pantel, 2000; [Pr] Pruessner, 2000; [S] Soininen, 1994; [W] Watson, 1992). The hippocampi of one healthy control and one AD patient taken from the 1.5T MR ADNI database were segmented by a single rater according to each protocol. The accuracy of the protocols interpretation and translation into practice was checked with lead authors of protocols through individual interactive web conferences. Semantically harmonized landmarks and differences were then extracted, regarding: (a) the posteriormost slice, protocol [B] being the most restrictive, and [H, M, Pa, Pr, S] the most inclusive; (b) inclusion [C, dTM, J, L, M, Pr, W] or exclusion [B, H, K, Pa, S] of alveus/fimbria; (c) separation from the parahippocampal gyrus, [C] being the most restrictive, [B, dTM, H, J, Pa, S] the most inclusive. There were no substantial differences in the definition of the anteriormost slice. This survey will allow us to operationalize differences among protocols into tracing units, measure their impact on the repeatability and diagnostic accuracy of manual hippocampal segmentation, and finally develop a harmonized protocol.",
keywords = "Alzheimers disease, anatomical landmark, atrophy, degeneration, harmonization, Hippocampus, manual segmentation protocol, manual tracing, medial temporal lobes, MRI",
author = "Marina Boccardi and Rossana Ganzola and Martina Bocchetta and Michela Pievani and Alberto Redolfi and George Bartzokis and Richard Camicioli and Csernansky, {John G.} and {De Leon}, {Mony J.} and Leyla Detoledo-Morrell and Killiany, {Ronald J.} and St{\'e}phane Leh{\'e}ricy and Johannes Pantel and Pruessner, {Jens C.} and H. Soininen and Craig Watson and Simon Duchesne and Jack, {Clifford R.} and Frisoni, {Giovanni B.}",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.3233/JAD-2011-0004",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "26",
pages = "61--75",
journal = "Journal of Alzheimer's Disease",
issn = "1387-2877",
publisher = "IOS Press",
number = "SUPPL. 3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Survey of protocols for the manual segmentation of the hippocampus

T2 - Preparatory steps towards a joint EADC-ADNI harmonized protocol

AU - Boccardi, Marina

AU - Ganzola, Rossana

AU - Bocchetta, Martina

AU - Pievani, Michela

AU - Redolfi, Alberto

AU - Bartzokis, George

AU - Camicioli, Richard

AU - Csernansky, John G.

AU - De Leon, Mony J.

AU - Detoledo-Morrell, Leyla

AU - Killiany, Ronald J.

AU - Lehéricy, Stéphane

AU - Pantel, Johannes

AU - Pruessner, Jens C.

AU - Soininen, H.

AU - Watson, Craig

AU - Duchesne, Simon

AU - Jack, Clifford R.

AU - Frisoni, Giovanni B.

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Manual segmentation from magnetic resonance imaging (MR) is the gold standard for evaluating hippocampal atrophy in Alzheimers disease (AD). Nonetheless, different segmentation protocols provide up to 2.5-fold volume differences. Here we surveyed the most frequently used segmentation protocols in the AD literature as a preliminary step for international harmonization. The anatomical landmarks (anteriormost and posteriormost slices, superior, inferior, medial, and lateral borders) were identified from 12 published protocols for hippocampal manual segmentation ([Abbreviation] first author, publication year: [B] Bartzokis, 1998; [C] Convit, 1997; [dTM] deToledo-Morrell, 2004; [H] Haller, 1997; [J] Jack, 1994; [K] Killiany, 1993; [L] Lehericy, 1994; [M] Malykhin, 2007; [Pa] Pantel, 2000; [Pr] Pruessner, 2000; [S] Soininen, 1994; [W] Watson, 1992). The hippocampi of one healthy control and one AD patient taken from the 1.5T MR ADNI database were segmented by a single rater according to each protocol. The accuracy of the protocols interpretation and translation into practice was checked with lead authors of protocols through individual interactive web conferences. Semantically harmonized landmarks and differences were then extracted, regarding: (a) the posteriormost slice, protocol [B] being the most restrictive, and [H, M, Pa, Pr, S] the most inclusive; (b) inclusion [C, dTM, J, L, M, Pr, W] or exclusion [B, H, K, Pa, S] of alveus/fimbria; (c) separation from the parahippocampal gyrus, [C] being the most restrictive, [B, dTM, H, J, Pa, S] the most inclusive. There were no substantial differences in the definition of the anteriormost slice. This survey will allow us to operationalize differences among protocols into tracing units, measure their impact on the repeatability and diagnostic accuracy of manual hippocampal segmentation, and finally develop a harmonized protocol.

AB - Manual segmentation from magnetic resonance imaging (MR) is the gold standard for evaluating hippocampal atrophy in Alzheimers disease (AD). Nonetheless, different segmentation protocols provide up to 2.5-fold volume differences. Here we surveyed the most frequently used segmentation protocols in the AD literature as a preliminary step for international harmonization. The anatomical landmarks (anteriormost and posteriormost slices, superior, inferior, medial, and lateral borders) were identified from 12 published protocols for hippocampal manual segmentation ([Abbreviation] first author, publication year: [B] Bartzokis, 1998; [C] Convit, 1997; [dTM] deToledo-Morrell, 2004; [H] Haller, 1997; [J] Jack, 1994; [K] Killiany, 1993; [L] Lehericy, 1994; [M] Malykhin, 2007; [Pa] Pantel, 2000; [Pr] Pruessner, 2000; [S] Soininen, 1994; [W] Watson, 1992). The hippocampi of one healthy control and one AD patient taken from the 1.5T MR ADNI database were segmented by a single rater according to each protocol. The accuracy of the protocols interpretation and translation into practice was checked with lead authors of protocols through individual interactive web conferences. Semantically harmonized landmarks and differences were then extracted, regarding: (a) the posteriormost slice, protocol [B] being the most restrictive, and [H, M, Pa, Pr, S] the most inclusive; (b) inclusion [C, dTM, J, L, M, Pr, W] or exclusion [B, H, K, Pa, S] of alveus/fimbria; (c) separation from the parahippocampal gyrus, [C] being the most restrictive, [B, dTM, H, J, Pa, S] the most inclusive. There were no substantial differences in the definition of the anteriormost slice. This survey will allow us to operationalize differences among protocols into tracing units, measure their impact on the repeatability and diagnostic accuracy of manual hippocampal segmentation, and finally develop a harmonized protocol.

KW - Alzheimers disease

KW - anatomical landmark

KW - atrophy

KW - degeneration

KW - harmonization

KW - Hippocampus

KW - manual segmentation protocol

KW - manual tracing

KW - medial temporal lobes

KW - MRI

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=80055063466&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=80055063466&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3233/JAD-2011-0004

DO - 10.3233/JAD-2011-0004

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 61

EP - 75

JO - Journal of Alzheimer's Disease

JF - Journal of Alzheimer's Disease

SN - 1387-2877

IS - SUPPL. 3

ER -