Risk factors for coliform bacteria in backcountry lakes and streams in the Sierra Nevada Mountains: A 5-year study

Robert W. Derlet, K. Ali Ger, John R Richards, James R. Carlson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. - To provide a 5-year longitudinal assessment of risk of acquiring disease from Sierra Nevada Wilderness area lakes and streams. This study examines the relative risk factors for harmful water microorganisms, using coliforms as an indicator. Methods. - Streams and lakes in the backcountry of Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks and neighboring wilderness areas were selected and water was analyzed each year over a 5-year period. A total of 364 samples from lakes or streams were chosen to statistically differentiate the risk categories based on land usage, as follows: 1) areas rarely visited by humans (Wild), 2) human day-use-only areas (Day Hike), 3) areas used by backpackers with overnight camping allowed (Backpack), 4) areas primarily impacted by horses or pack animals (Pack Animal), and 5) cattle and sheep grazing tracts (Cattle). Water was collected in sterile test tubes and Millipore coliform samplers. Water was analyzed at the university microbiology lab, where bacteria were harvested and then subjected to analysis using standardized techniques. Statistical analysis to compare site categories was performed utilizing Fisher exact test and analysis of variance. Results. - A total of 364 sampling sites were analyzed. Coliforms were found in 9% (4/47) of Wild site samples, 12% (5/42) of Day Hike site samples, and 18% (20/111) of Backpacker site samples. In contrast, 63% (70/111) of Pack Animal site samples yielded coliforms, and 96% (51/53) of samples from the Cattle areas grew coliforms. Differences between Backpacker vs Cattle or Pack Animal areas were significant at P ≤ .05. All samples grew normal aquatic bacteria. Conclusion. - Surface water from watersheds below cattle areas and those used by pack animals is at high risk for containing coliform organisms. Water from Wild, Day Hike, or Backpack sites poses far less risk for contamination by coliforms.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)82-90
Number of pages9
JournalWilderness and Environmental Medicine
Volume19
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - 2008

Fingerprint

Lakes
Bacteria
Water
Wilderness
Camping
Microbiology
Horses
Sheep
Analysis of Variance

Keywords

  • Cattle
  • Coliforms
  • Kings Canyon National Park
  • Sierra Nevada Mountains
  • Water
  • Yosemite National Park

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine
  • Physical Therapy, Sports Therapy and Rehabilitation
  • Orthopedics and Sports Medicine

Cite this

Risk factors for coliform bacteria in backcountry lakes and streams in the Sierra Nevada Mountains : A 5-year study. / Derlet, Robert W.; Ger, K. Ali; Richards, John R; Carlson, James R.

In: Wilderness and Environmental Medicine, Vol. 19, No. 2, 2008, p. 82-90.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{159d8376ae26446cb08fd12fa444ad9b,
title = "Risk factors for coliform bacteria in backcountry lakes and streams in the Sierra Nevada Mountains: A 5-year study",
abstract = "Objective. - To provide a 5-year longitudinal assessment of risk of acquiring disease from Sierra Nevada Wilderness area lakes and streams. This study examines the relative risk factors for harmful water microorganisms, using coliforms as an indicator. Methods. - Streams and lakes in the backcountry of Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks and neighboring wilderness areas were selected and water was analyzed each year over a 5-year period. A total of 364 samples from lakes or streams were chosen to statistically differentiate the risk categories based on land usage, as follows: 1) areas rarely visited by humans (Wild), 2) human day-use-only areas (Day Hike), 3) areas used by backpackers with overnight camping allowed (Backpack), 4) areas primarily impacted by horses or pack animals (Pack Animal), and 5) cattle and sheep grazing tracts (Cattle). Water was collected in sterile test tubes and Millipore coliform samplers. Water was analyzed at the university microbiology lab, where bacteria were harvested and then subjected to analysis using standardized techniques. Statistical analysis to compare site categories was performed utilizing Fisher exact test and analysis of variance. Results. - A total of 364 sampling sites were analyzed. Coliforms were found in 9{\%} (4/47) of Wild site samples, 12{\%} (5/42) of Day Hike site samples, and 18{\%} (20/111) of Backpacker site samples. In contrast, 63{\%} (70/111) of Pack Animal site samples yielded coliforms, and 96{\%} (51/53) of samples from the Cattle areas grew coliforms. Differences between Backpacker vs Cattle or Pack Animal areas were significant at P ≤ .05. All samples grew normal aquatic bacteria. Conclusion. - Surface water from watersheds below cattle areas and those used by pack animals is at high risk for containing coliform organisms. Water from Wild, Day Hike, or Backpack sites poses far less risk for contamination by coliforms.",
keywords = "Cattle, Coliforms, Kings Canyon National Park, Sierra Nevada Mountains, Water, Yosemite National Park",
author = "Derlet, {Robert W.} and Ger, {K. Ali} and Richards, {John R} and Carlson, {James R.}",
year = "2008",
doi = "10.1580/07-WEME-OR-1511.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "19",
pages = "82--90",
journal = "Wilderness and Environmental Medicine",
issn = "1080-6032",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Risk factors for coliform bacteria in backcountry lakes and streams in the Sierra Nevada Mountains

T2 - A 5-year study

AU - Derlet, Robert W.

AU - Ger, K. Ali

AU - Richards, John R

AU - Carlson, James R.

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Objective. - To provide a 5-year longitudinal assessment of risk of acquiring disease from Sierra Nevada Wilderness area lakes and streams. This study examines the relative risk factors for harmful water microorganisms, using coliforms as an indicator. Methods. - Streams and lakes in the backcountry of Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks and neighboring wilderness areas were selected and water was analyzed each year over a 5-year period. A total of 364 samples from lakes or streams were chosen to statistically differentiate the risk categories based on land usage, as follows: 1) areas rarely visited by humans (Wild), 2) human day-use-only areas (Day Hike), 3) areas used by backpackers with overnight camping allowed (Backpack), 4) areas primarily impacted by horses or pack animals (Pack Animal), and 5) cattle and sheep grazing tracts (Cattle). Water was collected in sterile test tubes and Millipore coliform samplers. Water was analyzed at the university microbiology lab, where bacteria were harvested and then subjected to analysis using standardized techniques. Statistical analysis to compare site categories was performed utilizing Fisher exact test and analysis of variance. Results. - A total of 364 sampling sites were analyzed. Coliforms were found in 9% (4/47) of Wild site samples, 12% (5/42) of Day Hike site samples, and 18% (20/111) of Backpacker site samples. In contrast, 63% (70/111) of Pack Animal site samples yielded coliforms, and 96% (51/53) of samples from the Cattle areas grew coliforms. Differences between Backpacker vs Cattle or Pack Animal areas were significant at P ≤ .05. All samples grew normal aquatic bacteria. Conclusion. - Surface water from watersheds below cattle areas and those used by pack animals is at high risk for containing coliform organisms. Water from Wild, Day Hike, or Backpack sites poses far less risk for contamination by coliforms.

AB - Objective. - To provide a 5-year longitudinal assessment of risk of acquiring disease from Sierra Nevada Wilderness area lakes and streams. This study examines the relative risk factors for harmful water microorganisms, using coliforms as an indicator. Methods. - Streams and lakes in the backcountry of Yosemite and Kings Canyon National Parks and neighboring wilderness areas were selected and water was analyzed each year over a 5-year period. A total of 364 samples from lakes or streams were chosen to statistically differentiate the risk categories based on land usage, as follows: 1) areas rarely visited by humans (Wild), 2) human day-use-only areas (Day Hike), 3) areas used by backpackers with overnight camping allowed (Backpack), 4) areas primarily impacted by horses or pack animals (Pack Animal), and 5) cattle and sheep grazing tracts (Cattle). Water was collected in sterile test tubes and Millipore coliform samplers. Water was analyzed at the university microbiology lab, where bacteria were harvested and then subjected to analysis using standardized techniques. Statistical analysis to compare site categories was performed utilizing Fisher exact test and analysis of variance. Results. - A total of 364 sampling sites were analyzed. Coliforms were found in 9% (4/47) of Wild site samples, 12% (5/42) of Day Hike site samples, and 18% (20/111) of Backpacker site samples. In contrast, 63% (70/111) of Pack Animal site samples yielded coliforms, and 96% (51/53) of samples from the Cattle areas grew coliforms. Differences between Backpacker vs Cattle or Pack Animal areas were significant at P ≤ .05. All samples grew normal aquatic bacteria. Conclusion. - Surface water from watersheds below cattle areas and those used by pack animals is at high risk for containing coliform organisms. Water from Wild, Day Hike, or Backpack sites poses far less risk for contamination by coliforms.

KW - Cattle

KW - Coliforms

KW - Kings Canyon National Park

KW - Sierra Nevada Mountains

KW - Water

KW - Yosemite National Park

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=45149103449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=45149103449&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1580/07-WEME-OR-1511.1

DO - 10.1580/07-WEME-OR-1511.1

M3 - Article

C2 - 18513116

AN - SCOPUS:45149103449

VL - 19

SP - 82

EP - 90

JO - Wilderness and Environmental Medicine

JF - Wilderness and Environmental Medicine

SN - 1080-6032

IS - 2

ER -