Re-utilization outcomes and costs of minor acute illness treated at family physician offices, walk-in clinics, and emergency departments.

M. Karen Campbell, Rachel Wulf Silver, Jeffrey S Hoch, Truls Østbye, Moira Stewart, Jan Barnsley, Brian Hutchison, Maria Mathews, Christine Tyrrell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

25 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To examine factors associated with re-utilization of health services and to estimate and compare costs of treatment for minor acute illnesses in family physicians' offices (FPOs), walk-in clinics (WICs), and emergency departments (EDs). DESIGN: Prospective cohort study using questionnaires, telephone follow up, medical chart data, and costs according to Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) schedules. SETTING: 16 FPOs, 12 WICs, and 13 EDs in three Ontario cities. PARTICIPANTS: Consecutive patients with one of eight predefined minor acute illnesses found in all three settings (upper respiratory infection, pharyngitis, acute bronchitis, acute otitis media, serous otitis media, low back pain, gastroenteritis, and urinary tract infection). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: "Early" (< 3 days) versus "later" (3 days to 2 weeks) re-utilization of health services after initial encounter and direct cost to OHIP. RESULTS: The overall rate of re-utilization of health services for the same episode of illness was 11.3% for early and 20.6% for later re-utilization. Factors associated with early re-utilization were initial evaluation in ED setting (odds ratio [OR] = 6.5, confidence interval [CI] = 2.2-19.2) and, regardless of setting, less satisfaction with patient-centred care (OR = 1.7 for each one-point decrease on a four-point scale; CI = 1.1-2.7). Factors associated with later re-utilization were ED setting (OR = 4.9; CI = 2.4-9.9) and diagnosis of urinary tract infection (OR = 2.4; CI = 1.1-5.2). Factors tested and found not signifcantly associated with rate of re-utilization were patients' age, sex, responses to a variety of questions assessing psychosocial factors (stress, social support, independence), and opinions on health care. Cost of care was similar for FPOs and WICs and higher for EDs for all diagnoses. The initial visit was the largest component of cost in all settings, and this component (as well as total cost) was consistently higher in EDs. CONCLUSION: Both re-utilization rates and costs are higher for those seeking care in EDs for minor acute illness. Patient-centred care, an important feature of health care encounters regardless of setting, can reduce re-utilization rates.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)82-83
Number of pages2
JournalCanadian family physician Médecin de famille canadien.
Volume51
StatePublished - Jan 2005
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Physicians' Offices
Family Physicians
Hospital Emergency Service
Costs and Cost Analysis
Ontario
Odds Ratio
Confidence Intervals
Health Services
Patient-Centered Care
Health Insurance
Urinary Tract Infections
Delivery of Health Care
Otitis Media with Effusion
Pharyngitis
Bronchitis
Gastroenteritis
Otitis Media
Low Back Pain
Telephone
Social Support

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Re-utilization outcomes and costs of minor acute illness treated at family physician offices, walk-in clinics, and emergency departments. / Campbell, M. Karen; Silver, Rachel Wulf; Hoch, Jeffrey S; Østbye, Truls; Stewart, Moira; Barnsley, Jan; Hutchison, Brian; Mathews, Maria; Tyrrell, Christine.

In: Canadian family physician Médecin de famille canadien., Vol. 51, 01.2005, p. 82-83.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Campbell, M. Karen ; Silver, Rachel Wulf ; Hoch, Jeffrey S ; Østbye, Truls ; Stewart, Moira ; Barnsley, Jan ; Hutchison, Brian ; Mathews, Maria ; Tyrrell, Christine. / Re-utilization outcomes and costs of minor acute illness treated at family physician offices, walk-in clinics, and emergency departments. In: Canadian family physician Médecin de famille canadien. 2005 ; Vol. 51. pp. 82-83.
@article{898a5d0735df4b0d9c3660c8aea8fcfd,
title = "Re-utilization outcomes and costs of minor acute illness treated at family physician offices, walk-in clinics, and emergency departments.",
abstract = "OBJECTIVE: To examine factors associated with re-utilization of health services and to estimate and compare costs of treatment for minor acute illnesses in family physicians' offices (FPOs), walk-in clinics (WICs), and emergency departments (EDs). DESIGN: Prospective cohort study using questionnaires, telephone follow up, medical chart data, and costs according to Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) schedules. SETTING: 16 FPOs, 12 WICs, and 13 EDs in three Ontario cities. PARTICIPANTS: Consecutive patients with one of eight predefined minor acute illnesses found in all three settings (upper respiratory infection, pharyngitis, acute bronchitis, acute otitis media, serous otitis media, low back pain, gastroenteritis, and urinary tract infection). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: {"}Early{"} (< 3 days) versus {"}later{"} (3 days to 2 weeks) re-utilization of health services after initial encounter and direct cost to OHIP. RESULTS: The overall rate of re-utilization of health services for the same episode of illness was 11.3{\%} for early and 20.6{\%} for later re-utilization. Factors associated with early re-utilization were initial evaluation in ED setting (odds ratio [OR] = 6.5, confidence interval [CI] = 2.2-19.2) and, regardless of setting, less satisfaction with patient-centred care (OR = 1.7 for each one-point decrease on a four-point scale; CI = 1.1-2.7). Factors associated with later re-utilization were ED setting (OR = 4.9; CI = 2.4-9.9) and diagnosis of urinary tract infection (OR = 2.4; CI = 1.1-5.2). Factors tested and found not signifcantly associated with rate of re-utilization were patients' age, sex, responses to a variety of questions assessing psychosocial factors (stress, social support, independence), and opinions on health care. Cost of care was similar for FPOs and WICs and higher for EDs for all diagnoses. The initial visit was the largest component of cost in all settings, and this component (as well as total cost) was consistently higher in EDs. CONCLUSION: Both re-utilization rates and costs are higher for those seeking care in EDs for minor acute illness. Patient-centred care, an important feature of health care encounters regardless of setting, can reduce re-utilization rates.",
author = "Campbell, {M. Karen} and Silver, {Rachel Wulf} and Hoch, {Jeffrey S} and Truls {\O}stbye and Moira Stewart and Jan Barnsley and Brian Hutchison and Maria Mathews and Christine Tyrrell",
year = "2005",
month = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "51",
pages = "82--83",
journal = "Canadian Family Physician",
issn = "0008-350X",
publisher = "College of Family Physicians of Canada",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Re-utilization outcomes and costs of minor acute illness treated at family physician offices, walk-in clinics, and emergency departments.

AU - Campbell, M. Karen

AU - Silver, Rachel Wulf

AU - Hoch, Jeffrey S

AU - Østbye, Truls

AU - Stewart, Moira

AU - Barnsley, Jan

AU - Hutchison, Brian

AU - Mathews, Maria

AU - Tyrrell, Christine

PY - 2005/1

Y1 - 2005/1

N2 - OBJECTIVE: To examine factors associated with re-utilization of health services and to estimate and compare costs of treatment for minor acute illnesses in family physicians' offices (FPOs), walk-in clinics (WICs), and emergency departments (EDs). DESIGN: Prospective cohort study using questionnaires, telephone follow up, medical chart data, and costs according to Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) schedules. SETTING: 16 FPOs, 12 WICs, and 13 EDs in three Ontario cities. PARTICIPANTS: Consecutive patients with one of eight predefined minor acute illnesses found in all three settings (upper respiratory infection, pharyngitis, acute bronchitis, acute otitis media, serous otitis media, low back pain, gastroenteritis, and urinary tract infection). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: "Early" (< 3 days) versus "later" (3 days to 2 weeks) re-utilization of health services after initial encounter and direct cost to OHIP. RESULTS: The overall rate of re-utilization of health services for the same episode of illness was 11.3% for early and 20.6% for later re-utilization. Factors associated with early re-utilization were initial evaluation in ED setting (odds ratio [OR] = 6.5, confidence interval [CI] = 2.2-19.2) and, regardless of setting, less satisfaction with patient-centred care (OR = 1.7 for each one-point decrease on a four-point scale; CI = 1.1-2.7). Factors associated with later re-utilization were ED setting (OR = 4.9; CI = 2.4-9.9) and diagnosis of urinary tract infection (OR = 2.4; CI = 1.1-5.2). Factors tested and found not signifcantly associated with rate of re-utilization were patients' age, sex, responses to a variety of questions assessing psychosocial factors (stress, social support, independence), and opinions on health care. Cost of care was similar for FPOs and WICs and higher for EDs for all diagnoses. The initial visit was the largest component of cost in all settings, and this component (as well as total cost) was consistently higher in EDs. CONCLUSION: Both re-utilization rates and costs are higher for those seeking care in EDs for minor acute illness. Patient-centred care, an important feature of health care encounters regardless of setting, can reduce re-utilization rates.

AB - OBJECTIVE: To examine factors associated with re-utilization of health services and to estimate and compare costs of treatment for minor acute illnesses in family physicians' offices (FPOs), walk-in clinics (WICs), and emergency departments (EDs). DESIGN: Prospective cohort study using questionnaires, telephone follow up, medical chart data, and costs according to Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) schedules. SETTING: 16 FPOs, 12 WICs, and 13 EDs in three Ontario cities. PARTICIPANTS: Consecutive patients with one of eight predefined minor acute illnesses found in all three settings (upper respiratory infection, pharyngitis, acute bronchitis, acute otitis media, serous otitis media, low back pain, gastroenteritis, and urinary tract infection). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: "Early" (< 3 days) versus "later" (3 days to 2 weeks) re-utilization of health services after initial encounter and direct cost to OHIP. RESULTS: The overall rate of re-utilization of health services for the same episode of illness was 11.3% for early and 20.6% for later re-utilization. Factors associated with early re-utilization were initial evaluation in ED setting (odds ratio [OR] = 6.5, confidence interval [CI] = 2.2-19.2) and, regardless of setting, less satisfaction with patient-centred care (OR = 1.7 for each one-point decrease on a four-point scale; CI = 1.1-2.7). Factors associated with later re-utilization were ED setting (OR = 4.9; CI = 2.4-9.9) and diagnosis of urinary tract infection (OR = 2.4; CI = 1.1-5.2). Factors tested and found not signifcantly associated with rate of re-utilization were patients' age, sex, responses to a variety of questions assessing psychosocial factors (stress, social support, independence), and opinions on health care. Cost of care was similar for FPOs and WICs and higher for EDs for all diagnoses. The initial visit was the largest component of cost in all settings, and this component (as well as total cost) was consistently higher in EDs. CONCLUSION: Both re-utilization rates and costs are higher for those seeking care in EDs for minor acute illness. Patient-centred care, an important feature of health care encounters regardless of setting, can reduce re-utilization rates.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=26944441806&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=26944441806&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 16926958

AN - SCOPUS:26944441806

VL - 51

SP - 82

EP - 83

JO - Canadian Family Physician

JF - Canadian Family Physician

SN - 0008-350X

ER -