Physician personality characteristics and inquiry about mood symptoms in primary care

Paul R. Duberstein, Benjamin P. Chapman, Ronald M. Epstein, Kelly R. McCollumn, Richard L Kravitz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Depression treatment is often initially sought from primary care physicians. OBJECTIVE: To explore the influence of physician personality on depression assessments. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of data collected in a randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Offices of primary care physicians in Rochester, NY. PARTICIPANTS: Forty-six physicians; six female actors. INTERVENTION: Eighty-six unannounced standardized patient (SPs) visits; physicians saw one SP with major depression and one with adjustment disorder. MEASUREMENTS: SPs listened to audiotapes and completed a form on doctoring behaviors and symptom inquiry immediately following the visit. For the assessment of diagnostic documentation, SPs' medical records were reviewed. Physician personality was assessed via items from the NEO-PI-R. RESULTS: Physicians who are more dutiful and more vulnerable were more likely to document a diagnosis of depression; those who are more dutiful also asked fewer questions concerning mood symptoms. LIMITATION: Roles portrayed by the SPs may not reflect the experience of a typical primary care patient. Most of the PCPs were white men. The sample of PCPs was limited to a single geographic location. Effect sizes were modest. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical, educational, and translational, implications of research showing that physician personality traits could affect practice behaviors warrant consideration. Current models of treatment for depression in primary care could be engineered to accommodate the variability in physician personality. Given that there is no single "correct" way to ask about mood disorders or suicide, clinicians are encouraged to adopt an approach that fits their personal style and preferences.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1791-1795
Number of pages5
JournalJournal of General Internal Medicine
Volume23
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 2008

Fingerprint

Personality
Primary Health Care
Physicians
Depression
Primary Care Physicians
Tape Recording
Adjustment Disorders
Geographic Locations
Translational Medical Research
Mood Disorders
Documentation
Suicide
Medical Records
Randomized Controlled Trials
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Depression
  • Mental health
  • Physician personality
  • Primary care
  • Suicide

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Internal Medicine

Cite this

Physician personality characteristics and inquiry about mood symptoms in primary care. / Duberstein, Paul R.; Chapman, Benjamin P.; Epstein, Ronald M.; McCollumn, Kelly R.; Kravitz, Richard L.

In: Journal of General Internal Medicine, Vol. 23, No. 11, 11.2008, p. 1791-1795.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Duberstein, Paul R. ; Chapman, Benjamin P. ; Epstein, Ronald M. ; McCollumn, Kelly R. ; Kravitz, Richard L. / Physician personality characteristics and inquiry about mood symptoms in primary care. In: Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2008 ; Vol. 23, No. 11. pp. 1791-1795.
@article{0b0bd00c87ab4cae8446f540a54d1b21,
title = "Physician personality characteristics and inquiry about mood symptoms in primary care",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Depression treatment is often initially sought from primary care physicians. OBJECTIVE: To explore the influence of physician personality on depression assessments. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of data collected in a randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Offices of primary care physicians in Rochester, NY. PARTICIPANTS: Forty-six physicians; six female actors. INTERVENTION: Eighty-six unannounced standardized patient (SPs) visits; physicians saw one SP with major depression and one with adjustment disorder. MEASUREMENTS: SPs listened to audiotapes and completed a form on doctoring behaviors and symptom inquiry immediately following the visit. For the assessment of diagnostic documentation, SPs' medical records were reviewed. Physician personality was assessed via items from the NEO-PI-R. RESULTS: Physicians who are more dutiful and more vulnerable were more likely to document a diagnosis of depression; those who are more dutiful also asked fewer questions concerning mood symptoms. LIMITATION: Roles portrayed by the SPs may not reflect the experience of a typical primary care patient. Most of the PCPs were white men. The sample of PCPs was limited to a single geographic location. Effect sizes were modest. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical, educational, and translational, implications of research showing that physician personality traits could affect practice behaviors warrant consideration. Current models of treatment for depression in primary care could be engineered to accommodate the variability in physician personality. Given that there is no single {"}correct{"} way to ask about mood disorders or suicide, clinicians are encouraged to adopt an approach that fits their personal style and preferences.",
keywords = "Depression, Mental health, Physician personality, Primary care, Suicide",
author = "Duberstein, {Paul R.} and Chapman, {Benjamin P.} and Epstein, {Ronald M.} and McCollumn, {Kelly R.} and Kravitz, {Richard L}",
year = "2008",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1007/s11606-008-0780-0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "23",
pages = "1791--1795",
journal = "Journal of General Internal Medicine",
issn = "0884-8734",
publisher = "Springer New York",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Physician personality characteristics and inquiry about mood symptoms in primary care

AU - Duberstein, Paul R.

AU - Chapman, Benjamin P.

AU - Epstein, Ronald M.

AU - McCollumn, Kelly R.

AU - Kravitz, Richard L

PY - 2008/11

Y1 - 2008/11

N2 - BACKGROUND: Depression treatment is often initially sought from primary care physicians. OBJECTIVE: To explore the influence of physician personality on depression assessments. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of data collected in a randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Offices of primary care physicians in Rochester, NY. PARTICIPANTS: Forty-six physicians; six female actors. INTERVENTION: Eighty-six unannounced standardized patient (SPs) visits; physicians saw one SP with major depression and one with adjustment disorder. MEASUREMENTS: SPs listened to audiotapes and completed a form on doctoring behaviors and symptom inquiry immediately following the visit. For the assessment of diagnostic documentation, SPs' medical records were reviewed. Physician personality was assessed via items from the NEO-PI-R. RESULTS: Physicians who are more dutiful and more vulnerable were more likely to document a diagnosis of depression; those who are more dutiful also asked fewer questions concerning mood symptoms. LIMITATION: Roles portrayed by the SPs may not reflect the experience of a typical primary care patient. Most of the PCPs were white men. The sample of PCPs was limited to a single geographic location. Effect sizes were modest. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical, educational, and translational, implications of research showing that physician personality traits could affect practice behaviors warrant consideration. Current models of treatment for depression in primary care could be engineered to accommodate the variability in physician personality. Given that there is no single "correct" way to ask about mood disorders or suicide, clinicians are encouraged to adopt an approach that fits their personal style and preferences.

AB - BACKGROUND: Depression treatment is often initially sought from primary care physicians. OBJECTIVE: To explore the influence of physician personality on depression assessments. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of data collected in a randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Offices of primary care physicians in Rochester, NY. PARTICIPANTS: Forty-six physicians; six female actors. INTERVENTION: Eighty-six unannounced standardized patient (SPs) visits; physicians saw one SP with major depression and one with adjustment disorder. MEASUREMENTS: SPs listened to audiotapes and completed a form on doctoring behaviors and symptom inquiry immediately following the visit. For the assessment of diagnostic documentation, SPs' medical records were reviewed. Physician personality was assessed via items from the NEO-PI-R. RESULTS: Physicians who are more dutiful and more vulnerable were more likely to document a diagnosis of depression; those who are more dutiful also asked fewer questions concerning mood symptoms. LIMITATION: Roles portrayed by the SPs may not reflect the experience of a typical primary care patient. Most of the PCPs were white men. The sample of PCPs was limited to a single geographic location. Effect sizes were modest. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical, educational, and translational, implications of research showing that physician personality traits could affect practice behaviors warrant consideration. Current models of treatment for depression in primary care could be engineered to accommodate the variability in physician personality. Given that there is no single "correct" way to ask about mood disorders or suicide, clinicians are encouraged to adopt an approach that fits their personal style and preferences.

KW - Depression

KW - Mental health

KW - Physician personality

KW - Primary care

KW - Suicide

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=56749156474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=56749156474&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s11606-008-0780-0

DO - 10.1007/s11606-008-0780-0

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 1791

EP - 1795

JO - Journal of General Internal Medicine

JF - Journal of General Internal Medicine

SN - 0884-8734

IS - 11

ER -