Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria: Are they realistic?

Marion R. Sills, Zhihuan J. Huang, Cheng Shao, Mark F. Guagliardo, James M. Chamberlain, Jill G Joseph

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective. Guidelines for inpatient length of stay (LOS) have been developed by several groups; among the most widely applied are those published by Milliman and Robertson (MandR). Few published reports have examined the relationship of actual practice to such guidelines, none in pediatric populations. This study was designed to compare pediatric practice in a large and defined population to M and R LOS criteria. Methods. Administrative data from New York State in 1995 were used to examine LOS for discharges corresponding to 16 selected pediatric diagnoses for which MandR publishes guidelines. Outliers, defined as the 2% of discharges with the longest LOS, were eliminated. The distribution of LOS for each diagnosis was compared with MandR LOS guidelines. Results. In New York State during 1995, pediatric LOS was markedly divergent from MandR guidelines. In general, the percentage of discharges in excess of the criterion LOS was less for nonmandatory admissions (croup: 23%, gastroenteritis: 44%, and pneumonia: 48%) than for those requiring surgery (uncomplicated appendectomy: 67%, pyloromyotomy: 62%, and major but noncritical bums: 64%) or prolonged treatment with antibiotics (bacterial meningitis: 91% and osteomyelitis: 86%). Conclusions. In New York State during 1995, LOS for selected pediatric conditions was generally in excess of published MandR guidelines. This raises concern about the potential effects of such guidelines on both patients and the hospitals caring for them. While endorsing the need for cost-effective practice, we call attention to the methods used to develop and validate guidelines.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)733-737
Number of pages5
JournalPediatrics
Volume105
Issue number4 I
StatePublished - Apr 2000
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Length of Stay
Pediatrics
Guidelines
Croup
Bacterial Meningitides
Appendectomy
Gastroenteritis
Osteomyelitis
Population
Inpatients
Pneumonia
Anti-Bacterial Agents
Costs and Cost Analysis

Keywords

  • Administrative data
  • Length of stay
  • Managed health care
  • Pediatrics
  • Practice guidelines

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health

Cite this

Sills, M. R., Huang, Z. J., Shao, C., Guagliardo, M. F., Chamberlain, J. M., & Joseph, J. G. (2000). Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria: Are they realistic? Pediatrics, 105(4 I), 733-737.

Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria : Are they realistic? / Sills, Marion R.; Huang, Zhihuan J.; Shao, Cheng; Guagliardo, Mark F.; Chamberlain, James M.; Joseph, Jill G.

In: Pediatrics, Vol. 105, No. 4 I, 04.2000, p. 733-737.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Sills, MR, Huang, ZJ, Shao, C, Guagliardo, MF, Chamberlain, JM & Joseph, JG 2000, 'Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria: Are they realistic?', Pediatrics, vol. 105, no. 4 I, pp. 733-737.
Sills MR, Huang ZJ, Shao C, Guagliardo MF, Chamberlain JM, Joseph JG. Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria: Are they realistic? Pediatrics. 2000 Apr;105(4 I):733-737.
Sills, Marion R. ; Huang, Zhihuan J. ; Shao, Cheng ; Guagliardo, Mark F. ; Chamberlain, James M. ; Joseph, Jill G. / Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria : Are they realistic?. In: Pediatrics. 2000 ; Vol. 105, No. 4 I. pp. 733-737.
@article{d19597a3c39e4850b97a858d29699dd1,
title = "Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria: Are they realistic?",
abstract = "Objective. Guidelines for inpatient length of stay (LOS) have been developed by several groups; among the most widely applied are those published by Milliman and Robertson (MandR). Few published reports have examined the relationship of actual practice to such guidelines, none in pediatric populations. This study was designed to compare pediatric practice in a large and defined population to M and R LOS criteria. Methods. Administrative data from New York State in 1995 were used to examine LOS for discharges corresponding to 16 selected pediatric diagnoses for which MandR publishes guidelines. Outliers, defined as the 2{\%} of discharges with the longest LOS, were eliminated. The distribution of LOS for each diagnosis was compared with MandR LOS guidelines. Results. In New York State during 1995, pediatric LOS was markedly divergent from MandR guidelines. In general, the percentage of discharges in excess of the criterion LOS was less for nonmandatory admissions (croup: 23{\%}, gastroenteritis: 44{\%}, and pneumonia: 48{\%}) than for those requiring surgery (uncomplicated appendectomy: 67{\%}, pyloromyotomy: 62{\%}, and major but noncritical bums: 64{\%}) or prolonged treatment with antibiotics (bacterial meningitis: 91{\%} and osteomyelitis: 86{\%}). Conclusions. In New York State during 1995, LOS for selected pediatric conditions was generally in excess of published MandR guidelines. This raises concern about the potential effects of such guidelines on both patients and the hospitals caring for them. While endorsing the need for cost-effective practice, we call attention to the methods used to develop and validate guidelines.",
keywords = "Administrative data, Length of stay, Managed health care, Pediatrics, Practice guidelines",
author = "Sills, {Marion R.} and Huang, {Zhihuan J.} and Cheng Shao and Guagliardo, {Mark F.} and Chamberlain, {James M.} and Joseph, {Jill G}",
year = "2000",
month = "4",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "105",
pages = "733--737",
journal = "Pediatrics",
issn = "0031-4005",
publisher = "American Academy of Pediatrics",
number = "4 I",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pediatric Milliman and Robertson length-of-stay criteria

T2 - Are they realistic?

AU - Sills, Marion R.

AU - Huang, Zhihuan J.

AU - Shao, Cheng

AU - Guagliardo, Mark F.

AU - Chamberlain, James M.

AU - Joseph, Jill G

PY - 2000/4

Y1 - 2000/4

N2 - Objective. Guidelines for inpatient length of stay (LOS) have been developed by several groups; among the most widely applied are those published by Milliman and Robertson (MandR). Few published reports have examined the relationship of actual practice to such guidelines, none in pediatric populations. This study was designed to compare pediatric practice in a large and defined population to M and R LOS criteria. Methods. Administrative data from New York State in 1995 were used to examine LOS for discharges corresponding to 16 selected pediatric diagnoses for which MandR publishes guidelines. Outliers, defined as the 2% of discharges with the longest LOS, were eliminated. The distribution of LOS for each diagnosis was compared with MandR LOS guidelines. Results. In New York State during 1995, pediatric LOS was markedly divergent from MandR guidelines. In general, the percentage of discharges in excess of the criterion LOS was less for nonmandatory admissions (croup: 23%, gastroenteritis: 44%, and pneumonia: 48%) than for those requiring surgery (uncomplicated appendectomy: 67%, pyloromyotomy: 62%, and major but noncritical bums: 64%) or prolonged treatment with antibiotics (bacterial meningitis: 91% and osteomyelitis: 86%). Conclusions. In New York State during 1995, LOS for selected pediatric conditions was generally in excess of published MandR guidelines. This raises concern about the potential effects of such guidelines on both patients and the hospitals caring for them. While endorsing the need for cost-effective practice, we call attention to the methods used to develop and validate guidelines.

AB - Objective. Guidelines for inpatient length of stay (LOS) have been developed by several groups; among the most widely applied are those published by Milliman and Robertson (MandR). Few published reports have examined the relationship of actual practice to such guidelines, none in pediatric populations. This study was designed to compare pediatric practice in a large and defined population to M and R LOS criteria. Methods. Administrative data from New York State in 1995 were used to examine LOS for discharges corresponding to 16 selected pediatric diagnoses for which MandR publishes guidelines. Outliers, defined as the 2% of discharges with the longest LOS, were eliminated. The distribution of LOS for each diagnosis was compared with MandR LOS guidelines. Results. In New York State during 1995, pediatric LOS was markedly divergent from MandR guidelines. In general, the percentage of discharges in excess of the criterion LOS was less for nonmandatory admissions (croup: 23%, gastroenteritis: 44%, and pneumonia: 48%) than for those requiring surgery (uncomplicated appendectomy: 67%, pyloromyotomy: 62%, and major but noncritical bums: 64%) or prolonged treatment with antibiotics (bacterial meningitis: 91% and osteomyelitis: 86%). Conclusions. In New York State during 1995, LOS for selected pediatric conditions was generally in excess of published MandR guidelines. This raises concern about the potential effects of such guidelines on both patients and the hospitals caring for them. While endorsing the need for cost-effective practice, we call attention to the methods used to develop and validate guidelines.

KW - Administrative data

KW - Length of stay

KW - Managed health care

KW - Pediatrics

KW - Practice guidelines

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034050810&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0034050810&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 10742312

AN - SCOPUS:0034050810

VL - 105

SP - 733

EP - 737

JO - Pediatrics

JF - Pediatrics

SN - 0031-4005

IS - 4 I

ER -