Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research

Rodolfo D Vicetti Miguel, Mamatha Chivukula, Uma Krishnamurti, Antonio J. Amortegui, Jeffrey A. Kant, Richard L Sweet, Harold C. Wiesenfeld, Jaclyn M. Phillips, Thomas L. Cherpes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

26 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

While endometrial neutrophils and plasma cells are criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) research, plasma cell misidentification and nonspecificity may limit the accuracy of these criteria. Herein, we examined: (1) the identification of endometrial plasma cells with conventional methyl green pyronin-based methodology versus plasma cell-specific (CD138) immunostaining, (2) the prevalence of endometrial plasma cells among women at low risk for PID, and (3) endometrial leukocyte subpopulations among women diagnosed with acute or chronic histologic endometritis by conventional criteria. We observed an absence of CD138+ cells in 25% of endometrial biopsies in which plasma cells had been identified by conventional methodology, while additional immunohistochemical analyses revealed indistinguishable inflammatory infiltrates among women diagnosed with acute or chronic endometritis by conventional criteria. Among women considered at lower risk for PID development, flow cytometric analyses detected plasma cells in 30% of endometrial biopsy specimens, suggesting that these cells, even when accurately identified, only nonspecifically identify upper genital tract inflammatory processes. Combined, our findings underscore the limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in PID-related research and suggest that satisfactory understanding of PID pathogenesis, treatment, and prevention is hindered by continued use of these criteria.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)680-685
Number of pages6
JournalPathology Research and Practice
Volume207
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 15 2011

Fingerprint

Endometritis
Pelvic Inflammatory Disease
Plasma Cells
Research
Methyl Green
Biopsy
Neutrophils
Leukocytes

Keywords

  • Histologic endometritis
  • Pelvic inflammatory disease
  • Plasma cell
  • Syndecan-1

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pathology and Forensic Medicine
  • Cell Biology

Cite this

Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research. / Miguel, Rodolfo D Vicetti; Chivukula, Mamatha; Krishnamurti, Uma; Amortegui, Antonio J.; Kant, Jeffrey A.; Sweet, Richard L; Wiesenfeld, Harold C.; Phillips, Jaclyn M.; Cherpes, Thomas L.

In: Pathology Research and Practice, Vol. 207, No. 11, 15.11.2011, p. 680-685.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Miguel, RDV, Chivukula, M, Krishnamurti, U, Amortegui, AJ, Kant, JA, Sweet, RL, Wiesenfeld, HC, Phillips, JM & Cherpes, TL 2011, 'Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research', Pathology Research and Practice, vol. 207, no. 11, pp. 680-685. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prp.2011.08.007
Miguel, Rodolfo D Vicetti ; Chivukula, Mamatha ; Krishnamurti, Uma ; Amortegui, Antonio J. ; Kant, Jeffrey A. ; Sweet, Richard L ; Wiesenfeld, Harold C. ; Phillips, Jaclyn M. ; Cherpes, Thomas L. / Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research. In: Pathology Research and Practice. 2011 ; Vol. 207, No. 11. pp. 680-685.
@article{b19f5ebca9c047dd9134226af82df5a8,
title = "Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research",
abstract = "While endometrial neutrophils and plasma cells are criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) research, plasma cell misidentification and nonspecificity may limit the accuracy of these criteria. Herein, we examined: (1) the identification of endometrial plasma cells with conventional methyl green pyronin-based methodology versus plasma cell-specific (CD138) immunostaining, (2) the prevalence of endometrial plasma cells among women at low risk for PID, and (3) endometrial leukocyte subpopulations among women diagnosed with acute or chronic histologic endometritis by conventional criteria. We observed an absence of CD138+ cells in 25{\%} of endometrial biopsies in which plasma cells had been identified by conventional methodology, while additional immunohistochemical analyses revealed indistinguishable inflammatory infiltrates among women diagnosed with acute or chronic endometritis by conventional criteria. Among women considered at lower risk for PID development, flow cytometric analyses detected plasma cells in 30{\%} of endometrial biopsy specimens, suggesting that these cells, even when accurately identified, only nonspecifically identify upper genital tract inflammatory processes. Combined, our findings underscore the limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in PID-related research and suggest that satisfactory understanding of PID pathogenesis, treatment, and prevention is hindered by continued use of these criteria.",
keywords = "Histologic endometritis, Pelvic inflammatory disease, Plasma cell, Syndecan-1",
author = "Miguel, {Rodolfo D Vicetti} and Mamatha Chivukula and Uma Krishnamurti and Amortegui, {Antonio J.} and Kant, {Jeffrey A.} and Sweet, {Richard L} and Wiesenfeld, {Harold C.} and Phillips, {Jaclyn M.} and Cherpes, {Thomas L.}",
year = "2011",
month = "11",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.prp.2011.08.007",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "207",
pages = "680--685",
journal = "Pathology Research and Practice",
issn = "0344-0338",
publisher = "Urban und Fischer Verlag GmbH und Co. KG",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease research

AU - Miguel, Rodolfo D Vicetti

AU - Chivukula, Mamatha

AU - Krishnamurti, Uma

AU - Amortegui, Antonio J.

AU - Kant, Jeffrey A.

AU - Sweet, Richard L

AU - Wiesenfeld, Harold C.

AU - Phillips, Jaclyn M.

AU - Cherpes, Thomas L.

PY - 2011/11/15

Y1 - 2011/11/15

N2 - While endometrial neutrophils and plasma cells are criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) research, plasma cell misidentification and nonspecificity may limit the accuracy of these criteria. Herein, we examined: (1) the identification of endometrial plasma cells with conventional methyl green pyronin-based methodology versus plasma cell-specific (CD138) immunostaining, (2) the prevalence of endometrial plasma cells among women at low risk for PID, and (3) endometrial leukocyte subpopulations among women diagnosed with acute or chronic histologic endometritis by conventional criteria. We observed an absence of CD138+ cells in 25% of endometrial biopsies in which plasma cells had been identified by conventional methodology, while additional immunohistochemical analyses revealed indistinguishable inflammatory infiltrates among women diagnosed with acute or chronic endometritis by conventional criteria. Among women considered at lower risk for PID development, flow cytometric analyses detected plasma cells in 30% of endometrial biopsy specimens, suggesting that these cells, even when accurately identified, only nonspecifically identify upper genital tract inflammatory processes. Combined, our findings underscore the limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in PID-related research and suggest that satisfactory understanding of PID pathogenesis, treatment, and prevention is hindered by continued use of these criteria.

AB - While endometrial neutrophils and plasma cells are criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in epidemiologic pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) research, plasma cell misidentification and nonspecificity may limit the accuracy of these criteria. Herein, we examined: (1) the identification of endometrial plasma cells with conventional methyl green pyronin-based methodology versus plasma cell-specific (CD138) immunostaining, (2) the prevalence of endometrial plasma cells among women at low risk for PID, and (3) endometrial leukocyte subpopulations among women diagnosed with acute or chronic histologic endometritis by conventional criteria. We observed an absence of CD138+ cells in 25% of endometrial biopsies in which plasma cells had been identified by conventional methodology, while additional immunohistochemical analyses revealed indistinguishable inflammatory infiltrates among women diagnosed with acute or chronic endometritis by conventional criteria. Among women considered at lower risk for PID development, flow cytometric analyses detected plasma cells in 30% of endometrial biopsy specimens, suggesting that these cells, even when accurately identified, only nonspecifically identify upper genital tract inflammatory processes. Combined, our findings underscore the limitations of the criteria used to diagnose histologic endometritis in PID-related research and suggest that satisfactory understanding of PID pathogenesis, treatment, and prevention is hindered by continued use of these criteria.

KW - Histologic endometritis

KW - Pelvic inflammatory disease

KW - Plasma cell

KW - Syndecan-1

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=82755182534&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=82755182534&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.prp.2011.08.007

DO - 10.1016/j.prp.2011.08.007

M3 - Article

VL - 207

SP - 680

EP - 685

JO - Pathology Research and Practice

JF - Pathology Research and Practice

SN - 0344-0338

IS - 11

ER -