Invited review: A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of mortality and culling in dairy cattle

C. W.R. Compton, C. Heuer, P. T. Thomsen, Tim Carpenter, C. V.C. Phyn, S. McDougall

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

33 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Dairy industries and individual farmers are concerned about mortality and culling of dairy animals. This is because the timing and fates of animals that exit dairy farms have important animal welfare and economic consequences that reflect the conditions under which they are farmed and the efficiency of their production systems. Reports from a few countries have indicated increased incidence of mortality, and occasionally culling, of dairy animals in recent decades, and these changes have been associated with intensification of production systems. Dairy industries and farmers need benchmarks for culling and mortality against which they can compare themselves, as well as improved understanding of the extent of any change and of any associated factors. We reasoned that a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of scientific articles published between 1989 and 2014 would allow us to determine whether these reports were universal, to quantify any change over time, and to investigate whether production systems or study factors were associated with culling and mortality. From 3,275 articles retrieved from databases and manual searching of cited articles, 118 articles were appraised independently by 2 assessors, and 51 articles representing 54 studies were determined to be eligible for review and meta-analysis. We estimated that both the annual incidence risk (IR) and incidence density of mortality of cows had increased significantly from 0.02 per cow and 2.32 per 100 cow-years, to 0.04 per cow and 3.75 per 100 cow-years, an increase per decade of 0.02 per cow and 1.42 per 100 cow-years, respectively. We also estimated that the annual IR of culling attributed to low production had declined significantly from 0.07 to 0.05 and that the IR of perinatal, but not neonatal, mortality had increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.06 per decade. We found no evidence of change in overall annual IR of culling of cows over time or any association between study design factors and the IR or incidence density of culling or mortality. These findings provide benchmarks for describing culling and mortality, and should encourage farmers and researchers in countries with modern dairy industries to discover and implement management strategies to reduce the animal welfare and economic costs associated with these changes.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-16
Number of pages16
JournalJournal of Dairy Science
Volume100
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

culling (animals)
meta-analysis
dairy cattle
Meta-Analysis
cows
incidence
Dairying
Mortality
Incidence
dairy industry
dairy animals
Benchmarking
Animal Welfare
production technology
farmers
animal welfare
Economics
neonatal mortality
economic costs
Infant Mortality

Keywords

  • culling
  • dairy cow
  • dairy replacement
  • mortality

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Food Science
  • Animal Science and Zoology
  • Genetics

Cite this

Invited review : A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of mortality and culling in dairy cattle. / Compton, C. W.R.; Heuer, C.; Thomsen, P. T.; Carpenter, Tim; Phyn, C. V.C.; McDougall, S.

In: Journal of Dairy Science, Vol. 100, No. 1, 01.01.2017, p. 1-16.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Compton, C. W.R. ; Heuer, C. ; Thomsen, P. T. ; Carpenter, Tim ; Phyn, C. V.C. ; McDougall, S. / Invited review : A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of mortality and culling in dairy cattle. In: Journal of Dairy Science. 2017 ; Vol. 100, No. 1. pp. 1-16.
@article{665e320e13a141178ed9bf47e2969f08,
title = "Invited review: A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of mortality and culling in dairy cattle",
abstract = "Dairy industries and individual farmers are concerned about mortality and culling of dairy animals. This is because the timing and fates of animals that exit dairy farms have important animal welfare and economic consequences that reflect the conditions under which they are farmed and the efficiency of their production systems. Reports from a few countries have indicated increased incidence of mortality, and occasionally culling, of dairy animals in recent decades, and these changes have been associated with intensification of production systems. Dairy industries and farmers need benchmarks for culling and mortality against which they can compare themselves, as well as improved understanding of the extent of any change and of any associated factors. We reasoned that a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of scientific articles published between 1989 and 2014 would allow us to determine whether these reports were universal, to quantify any change over time, and to investigate whether production systems or study factors were associated with culling and mortality. From 3,275 articles retrieved from databases and manual searching of cited articles, 118 articles were appraised independently by 2 assessors, and 51 articles representing 54 studies were determined to be eligible for review and meta-analysis. We estimated that both the annual incidence risk (IR) and incidence density of mortality of cows had increased significantly from 0.02 per cow and 2.32 per 100 cow-years, to 0.04 per cow and 3.75 per 100 cow-years, an increase per decade of 0.02 per cow and 1.42 per 100 cow-years, respectively. We also estimated that the annual IR of culling attributed to low production had declined significantly from 0.07 to 0.05 and that the IR of perinatal, but not neonatal, mortality had increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.06 per decade. We found no evidence of change in overall annual IR of culling of cows over time or any association between study design factors and the IR or incidence density of culling or mortality. These findings provide benchmarks for describing culling and mortality, and should encourage farmers and researchers in countries with modern dairy industries to discover and implement management strategies to reduce the animal welfare and economic costs associated with these changes.",
keywords = "culling, dairy cow, dairy replacement, mortality",
author = "Compton, {C. W.R.} and C. Heuer and Thomsen, {P. T.} and Tim Carpenter and Phyn, {C. V.C.} and S. McDougall",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3168/jds.2016-11302",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "100",
pages = "1--16",
journal = "Journal of Dairy Science",
issn = "0022-0302",
publisher = "Elsevier Limited",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Invited review

T2 - A systematic literature review and meta-analysis of mortality and culling in dairy cattle

AU - Compton, C. W.R.

AU - Heuer, C.

AU - Thomsen, P. T.

AU - Carpenter, Tim

AU - Phyn, C. V.C.

AU - McDougall, S.

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Dairy industries and individual farmers are concerned about mortality and culling of dairy animals. This is because the timing and fates of animals that exit dairy farms have important animal welfare and economic consequences that reflect the conditions under which they are farmed and the efficiency of their production systems. Reports from a few countries have indicated increased incidence of mortality, and occasionally culling, of dairy animals in recent decades, and these changes have been associated with intensification of production systems. Dairy industries and farmers need benchmarks for culling and mortality against which they can compare themselves, as well as improved understanding of the extent of any change and of any associated factors. We reasoned that a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of scientific articles published between 1989 and 2014 would allow us to determine whether these reports were universal, to quantify any change over time, and to investigate whether production systems or study factors were associated with culling and mortality. From 3,275 articles retrieved from databases and manual searching of cited articles, 118 articles were appraised independently by 2 assessors, and 51 articles representing 54 studies were determined to be eligible for review and meta-analysis. We estimated that both the annual incidence risk (IR) and incidence density of mortality of cows had increased significantly from 0.02 per cow and 2.32 per 100 cow-years, to 0.04 per cow and 3.75 per 100 cow-years, an increase per decade of 0.02 per cow and 1.42 per 100 cow-years, respectively. We also estimated that the annual IR of culling attributed to low production had declined significantly from 0.07 to 0.05 and that the IR of perinatal, but not neonatal, mortality had increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.06 per decade. We found no evidence of change in overall annual IR of culling of cows over time or any association between study design factors and the IR or incidence density of culling or mortality. These findings provide benchmarks for describing culling and mortality, and should encourage farmers and researchers in countries with modern dairy industries to discover and implement management strategies to reduce the animal welfare and economic costs associated with these changes.

AB - Dairy industries and individual farmers are concerned about mortality and culling of dairy animals. This is because the timing and fates of animals that exit dairy farms have important animal welfare and economic consequences that reflect the conditions under which they are farmed and the efficiency of their production systems. Reports from a few countries have indicated increased incidence of mortality, and occasionally culling, of dairy animals in recent decades, and these changes have been associated with intensification of production systems. Dairy industries and farmers need benchmarks for culling and mortality against which they can compare themselves, as well as improved understanding of the extent of any change and of any associated factors. We reasoned that a systematic literature review and meta-analysis of scientific articles published between 1989 and 2014 would allow us to determine whether these reports were universal, to quantify any change over time, and to investigate whether production systems or study factors were associated with culling and mortality. From 3,275 articles retrieved from databases and manual searching of cited articles, 118 articles were appraised independently by 2 assessors, and 51 articles representing 54 studies were determined to be eligible for review and meta-analysis. We estimated that both the annual incidence risk (IR) and incidence density of mortality of cows had increased significantly from 0.02 per cow and 2.32 per 100 cow-years, to 0.04 per cow and 3.75 per 100 cow-years, an increase per decade of 0.02 per cow and 1.42 per 100 cow-years, respectively. We also estimated that the annual IR of culling attributed to low production had declined significantly from 0.07 to 0.05 and that the IR of perinatal, but not neonatal, mortality had increased significantly from 0.04 to 0.06 per decade. We found no evidence of change in overall annual IR of culling of cows over time or any association between study design factors and the IR or incidence density of culling or mortality. These findings provide benchmarks for describing culling and mortality, and should encourage farmers and researchers in countries with modern dairy industries to discover and implement management strategies to reduce the animal welfare and economic costs associated with these changes.

KW - culling

KW - dairy cow

KW - dairy replacement

KW - mortality

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85005975802&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85005975802&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3168/jds.2016-11302

DO - 10.3168/jds.2016-11302

M3 - Article

C2 - 28341041

AN - SCOPUS:85005975802

VL - 100

SP - 1

EP - 16

JO - Journal of Dairy Science

JF - Journal of Dairy Science

SN - 0022-0302

IS - 1

ER -