Grid and slot scan scatter reduction in mammography: Comparison by using monte carlo techniques

John M Boone, J Anthony Seibert, Cha Mei Tang, Steve M. Lane

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

49 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

PURPOSE: To evaluate a comprehensive array of scatter cleanup techniques in mammography by using a consistent methodology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Monte Carlo techniques were used to evaluate the Bucky factor (BF) and the contrast improvement factor (CIF) for linear and cellular grids and for slot scan and scanning multiple-slot assembly (SMSA) systems. RESULTS: For a 28-kVp molybdenum anode-molybdenum filter spectrum with a standard detector and a 6-cm-thick 50% adipose-50% glandular breast phantom, slot scan techniques delivered an ideal BF. For slot widths greater than 4 mm, however, the CIF was lower than that achieved by the high-transmission cellular grid with a grid ratio of 3.8:1. A tungsten-septa air-interspaced cellular grid with a 4:1 grid ratio outperformed the high-transmission cellular grid in both BF and CIF. The SMSA was shown to be efficacious when 4-mm-wide slots were separated by at least 20 mm. In comparison with the literature, 3.6% agreement was achieved with other Monte Carlo studies, 3.3% with an experimental study that used a digital detector, and 13%-29% agreement was demonstrated in comparison to film-based experimental studies. CONCLUSION: With use of consistent methods for comparison, cellular grids were shown to substantially outperform linear grids but have slightly higher BFs compared with that of slot scan geometries at the same CIF.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)519-527
Number of pages9
JournalRadiology
Volume222
Issue number2
StatePublished - 2002

Fingerprint

Molybdenum
Mammography
Tungsten
Electrodes
Breast
Air

Keywords

  • Breast radiography, technology
  • Physics
  • Radiations

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiological and Ultrasound Technology

Cite this

Grid and slot scan scatter reduction in mammography : Comparison by using monte carlo techniques. / Boone, John M; Seibert, J Anthony; Tang, Cha Mei; Lane, Steve M.

In: Radiology, Vol. 222, No. 2, 2002, p. 519-527.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1a68f3db61004d2e96c5e17b12eabca4,
title = "Grid and slot scan scatter reduction in mammography: Comparison by using monte carlo techniques",
abstract = "PURPOSE: To evaluate a comprehensive array of scatter cleanup techniques in mammography by using a consistent methodology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Monte Carlo techniques were used to evaluate the Bucky factor (BF) and the contrast improvement factor (CIF) for linear and cellular grids and for slot scan and scanning multiple-slot assembly (SMSA) systems. RESULTS: For a 28-kVp molybdenum anode-molybdenum filter spectrum with a standard detector and a 6-cm-thick 50{\%} adipose-50{\%} glandular breast phantom, slot scan techniques delivered an ideal BF. For slot widths greater than 4 mm, however, the CIF was lower than that achieved by the high-transmission cellular grid with a grid ratio of 3.8:1. A tungsten-septa air-interspaced cellular grid with a 4:1 grid ratio outperformed the high-transmission cellular grid in both BF and CIF. The SMSA was shown to be efficacious when 4-mm-wide slots were separated by at least 20 mm. In comparison with the literature, 3.6{\%} agreement was achieved with other Monte Carlo studies, 3.3{\%} with an experimental study that used a digital detector, and 13{\%}-29{\%} agreement was demonstrated in comparison to film-based experimental studies. CONCLUSION: With use of consistent methods for comparison, cellular grids were shown to substantially outperform linear grids but have slightly higher BFs compared with that of slot scan geometries at the same CIF.",
keywords = "Breast radiography, technology, Physics, Radiations",
author = "Boone, {John M} and Seibert, {J Anthony} and Tang, {Cha Mei} and Lane, {Steve M.}",
year = "2002",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "222",
pages = "519--527",
journal = "Radiology",
issn = "0033-8419",
publisher = "Radiological Society of North America Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Grid and slot scan scatter reduction in mammography

T2 - Comparison by using monte carlo techniques

AU - Boone, John M

AU - Seibert, J Anthony

AU - Tang, Cha Mei

AU - Lane, Steve M.

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - PURPOSE: To evaluate a comprehensive array of scatter cleanup techniques in mammography by using a consistent methodology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Monte Carlo techniques were used to evaluate the Bucky factor (BF) and the contrast improvement factor (CIF) for linear and cellular grids and for slot scan and scanning multiple-slot assembly (SMSA) systems. RESULTS: For a 28-kVp molybdenum anode-molybdenum filter spectrum with a standard detector and a 6-cm-thick 50% adipose-50% glandular breast phantom, slot scan techniques delivered an ideal BF. For slot widths greater than 4 mm, however, the CIF was lower than that achieved by the high-transmission cellular grid with a grid ratio of 3.8:1. A tungsten-septa air-interspaced cellular grid with a 4:1 grid ratio outperformed the high-transmission cellular grid in both BF and CIF. The SMSA was shown to be efficacious when 4-mm-wide slots were separated by at least 20 mm. In comparison with the literature, 3.6% agreement was achieved with other Monte Carlo studies, 3.3% with an experimental study that used a digital detector, and 13%-29% agreement was demonstrated in comparison to film-based experimental studies. CONCLUSION: With use of consistent methods for comparison, cellular grids were shown to substantially outperform linear grids but have slightly higher BFs compared with that of slot scan geometries at the same CIF.

AB - PURPOSE: To evaluate a comprehensive array of scatter cleanup techniques in mammography by using a consistent methodology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Monte Carlo techniques were used to evaluate the Bucky factor (BF) and the contrast improvement factor (CIF) for linear and cellular grids and for slot scan and scanning multiple-slot assembly (SMSA) systems. RESULTS: For a 28-kVp molybdenum anode-molybdenum filter spectrum with a standard detector and a 6-cm-thick 50% adipose-50% glandular breast phantom, slot scan techniques delivered an ideal BF. For slot widths greater than 4 mm, however, the CIF was lower than that achieved by the high-transmission cellular grid with a grid ratio of 3.8:1. A tungsten-septa air-interspaced cellular grid with a 4:1 grid ratio outperformed the high-transmission cellular grid in both BF and CIF. The SMSA was shown to be efficacious when 4-mm-wide slots were separated by at least 20 mm. In comparison with the literature, 3.6% agreement was achieved with other Monte Carlo studies, 3.3% with an experimental study that used a digital detector, and 13%-29% agreement was demonstrated in comparison to film-based experimental studies. CONCLUSION: With use of consistent methods for comparison, cellular grids were shown to substantially outperform linear grids but have slightly higher BFs compared with that of slot scan geometries at the same CIF.

KW - Breast radiography, technology

KW - Physics

KW - Radiations

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0036151527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0036151527&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 11818623

AN - SCOPUS:0036151527

VL - 222

SP - 519

EP - 527

JO - Radiology

JF - Radiology

SN - 0033-8419

IS - 2

ER -