Evaluation of testing strategies for infectious salmon anaemia and implications for surveillance and control programs

P. Nérette, L. Hammell, I. Dohoo, Ian Gardner

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Infectious salmon anaemia (ISA) is an economically important disease in New Brunswick, Canada. Current regulatory control involves detection of ISAv in broodstock, hatcheries and marine sites through a surveillance program. Prior to recent assessments of operating characteristics of diagnostic tests, the efficiency of this surveillance program was difficult to evaluate. In order to determine the optimal testing strategies for various phases of production, a cost-effectiveness analysis was done for different strategies including single testing and multiple testing with results interpreted in series or in parallel. The lowest cost testing strategy, which would achieve a group-level sensitivity (GSe) of 95% and a group-level specificity (GSp) of 95%, was determined for each production phase. Our analyses showed that the most cost-effective testing strategy depended on the production phase. If sampling is to be carried out in a freshwater facility, then broodstock should be tested by VI alone, while pre-smolts should be tested with IFAT and VI used in series. For fish reared in saltwater, parallel interpretation of results from VI and RT-PCR, or testing with VI alone, are appropriate testing strategies for broodstock. For market-fish, PCR alone is a good screening option. If one assumes the prevalence of ISAv in moribund fish is at least 50%, then a maximum of 5 fish (at a cut-point of 1 positive fish to designate a cage as positive) need to be tested at a cost of $220. If one desired to have a perfect GSp (i.e. no false positive cage designations), serial testing with IFAT and VI is a better option. However, for this strategy a maximum of 9 fish (at a cut-point of 1) need to be tested at a cost of $472.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)53-59
Number of pages7
JournalAquaculture
Volume280
Issue number1-4
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2008

Fingerprint

infectious salmon anemia
anemia
monitoring
fish
breeding stock
testing
cost
cages
cost analysis
smolt
hatchery
evaluation
surveillance
programme
New Brunswick
smolts
cost effectiveness
production costs
marine fish
diagnostic techniques

Keywords

  • Cost-effectiveness analysis
  • Infectious salmon anaemia
  • Surveillance program
  • Testing strategies

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Aquatic Science

Cite this

Evaluation of testing strategies for infectious salmon anaemia and implications for surveillance and control programs. / Nérette, P.; Hammell, L.; Dohoo, I.; Gardner, Ian.

In: Aquaculture, Vol. 280, No. 1-4, 01.08.2008, p. 53-59.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{720f81724f44462b88b5b51e8801dc00,
title = "Evaluation of testing strategies for infectious salmon anaemia and implications for surveillance and control programs",
abstract = "Infectious salmon anaemia (ISA) is an economically important disease in New Brunswick, Canada. Current regulatory control involves detection of ISAv in broodstock, hatcheries and marine sites through a surveillance program. Prior to recent assessments of operating characteristics of diagnostic tests, the efficiency of this surveillance program was difficult to evaluate. In order to determine the optimal testing strategies for various phases of production, a cost-effectiveness analysis was done for different strategies including single testing and multiple testing with results interpreted in series or in parallel. The lowest cost testing strategy, which would achieve a group-level sensitivity (GSe) of 95{\%} and a group-level specificity (GSp) of 95{\%}, was determined for each production phase. Our analyses showed that the most cost-effective testing strategy depended on the production phase. If sampling is to be carried out in a freshwater facility, then broodstock should be tested by VI alone, while pre-smolts should be tested with IFAT and VI used in series. For fish reared in saltwater, parallel interpretation of results from VI and RT-PCR, or testing with VI alone, are appropriate testing strategies for broodstock. For market-fish, PCR alone is a good screening option. If one assumes the prevalence of ISAv in moribund fish is at least 50{\%}, then a maximum of 5 fish (at a cut-point of 1 positive fish to designate a cage as positive) need to be tested at a cost of $220. If one desired to have a perfect GSp (i.e. no false positive cage designations), serial testing with IFAT and VI is a better option. However, for this strategy a maximum of 9 fish (at a cut-point of 1) need to be tested at a cost of $472.",
keywords = "Cost-effectiveness analysis, Infectious salmon anaemia, Surveillance program, Testing strategies",
author = "P. N{\'e}rette and L. Hammell and I. Dohoo and Ian Gardner",
year = "2008",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.aquaculture.2008.04.016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "280",
pages = "53--59",
journal = "Aquaculture",
issn = "0044-8486",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1-4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of testing strategies for infectious salmon anaemia and implications for surveillance and control programs

AU - Nérette, P.

AU - Hammell, L.

AU - Dohoo, I.

AU - Gardner, Ian

PY - 2008/8/1

Y1 - 2008/8/1

N2 - Infectious salmon anaemia (ISA) is an economically important disease in New Brunswick, Canada. Current regulatory control involves detection of ISAv in broodstock, hatcheries and marine sites through a surveillance program. Prior to recent assessments of operating characteristics of diagnostic tests, the efficiency of this surveillance program was difficult to evaluate. In order to determine the optimal testing strategies for various phases of production, a cost-effectiveness analysis was done for different strategies including single testing and multiple testing with results interpreted in series or in parallel. The lowest cost testing strategy, which would achieve a group-level sensitivity (GSe) of 95% and a group-level specificity (GSp) of 95%, was determined for each production phase. Our analyses showed that the most cost-effective testing strategy depended on the production phase. If sampling is to be carried out in a freshwater facility, then broodstock should be tested by VI alone, while pre-smolts should be tested with IFAT and VI used in series. For fish reared in saltwater, parallel interpretation of results from VI and RT-PCR, or testing with VI alone, are appropriate testing strategies for broodstock. For market-fish, PCR alone is a good screening option. If one assumes the prevalence of ISAv in moribund fish is at least 50%, then a maximum of 5 fish (at a cut-point of 1 positive fish to designate a cage as positive) need to be tested at a cost of $220. If one desired to have a perfect GSp (i.e. no false positive cage designations), serial testing with IFAT and VI is a better option. However, for this strategy a maximum of 9 fish (at a cut-point of 1) need to be tested at a cost of $472.

AB - Infectious salmon anaemia (ISA) is an economically important disease in New Brunswick, Canada. Current regulatory control involves detection of ISAv in broodstock, hatcheries and marine sites through a surveillance program. Prior to recent assessments of operating characteristics of diagnostic tests, the efficiency of this surveillance program was difficult to evaluate. In order to determine the optimal testing strategies for various phases of production, a cost-effectiveness analysis was done for different strategies including single testing and multiple testing with results interpreted in series or in parallel. The lowest cost testing strategy, which would achieve a group-level sensitivity (GSe) of 95% and a group-level specificity (GSp) of 95%, was determined for each production phase. Our analyses showed that the most cost-effective testing strategy depended on the production phase. If sampling is to be carried out in a freshwater facility, then broodstock should be tested by VI alone, while pre-smolts should be tested with IFAT and VI used in series. For fish reared in saltwater, parallel interpretation of results from VI and RT-PCR, or testing with VI alone, are appropriate testing strategies for broodstock. For market-fish, PCR alone is a good screening option. If one assumes the prevalence of ISAv in moribund fish is at least 50%, then a maximum of 5 fish (at a cut-point of 1 positive fish to designate a cage as positive) need to be tested at a cost of $220. If one desired to have a perfect GSp (i.e. no false positive cage designations), serial testing with IFAT and VI is a better option. However, for this strategy a maximum of 9 fish (at a cut-point of 1) need to be tested at a cost of $472.

KW - Cost-effectiveness analysis

KW - Infectious salmon anaemia

KW - Surveillance program

KW - Testing strategies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=47249141912&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=47249141912&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2008.04.016

DO - 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2008.04.016

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:47249141912

VL - 280

SP - 53

EP - 59

JO - Aquaculture

JF - Aquaculture

SN - 0044-8486

IS - 1-4

ER -