Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter

Dalibor Breznan, Subramanian Karthikeyan, Marcelle Phaneuf, Prem Kumarathasan, Sabit Cakmak, Michael S. Denison, Jeffrey R. Brook, Renaud Vincent

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Association of particulate matter with adverse health effects has been established in epidemiological studies and animal experiments. Epidemiological studies are difficult to undertake while animal studies are impractical for high-throughput toxicity testing. The ease and rapidity of in vitro tests emphasizes their potential for use in risk assessment of chemicals and particles. We examined the association between in vitro and in vivo responses to ambient particles, to determine the potential of cell-based assays as standalone toxicity screening tools. Methods: Assays of cytotoxicity and key inflammatory mediators were applied to determine the in vitro biological potency of a panel of urban and mineral particles in J774A.1 macrophages and A549 lung epithelial cells. The particles were also screened for the presence of AhR agonists using the Ah receptor-dependent gene induction assay and for endotoxin using the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay. A subset of the particles with a contrasting in vitro toxicity profile was delivered intratracheally in BALB/c mice to assess their in vivo biological potency. Results from various bioassays were combined within the in vitro and in vivo models. The combined potency measures were examined for associations. Results: Overall, J774A.1 cells were more sensitive to particle effects than A549 cells. Whereas the combined cytotoxicity estimates were highly correlated between the two cell lines, the combined in vitro inflammatory potency estimates were not, emphasizing functional differences of the two cell types. Secretion of inflammatory markers by J774A.1 cells was correlated with AhR ligand binding profile and endotoxin levels of particles. Particle instillation led to an acute toxicity response in BALB/c mice, with neutrophilia and release of inflammatory mediators. While the combined toxicity estimates were not correlated between in vitro and in vivo models, the combined inflammatory and integrated potency estimates (toxicity and inflammation) approached the threshold for significance (p = 0.052) in a correlation within in vitro and in vivo models, with a ranking of fine particle (DWR1), minerals (TiO2, CRI) and coarse particles (SRM-, EHC-type) from low to high potency. Conclusion: Integration of in vitro endpoints shows promise in determining adverse outcomes of particle exposures in vivo. The devised data reduction and computational approach will prove useful in the development of models for assessment of hazard potential of particles; however, distinct models may be needed for particles of different type, such as urban particles vs. mineral particles, nanomaterials.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number41
JournalParticle and Fibre Toxicology
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - 2016

Fingerprint

Particulate Matter
Toxicity
Assays
Minerals
Cytotoxicity
Endotoxins
Animals
Bioassay
Epidemiologic Studies
Macrophages
Nanostructured materials
Risk assessment
In Vitro Techniques
Horseshoe Crabs
Data reduction
Hazards
Screening
Nanostructures
Genes
Cells

Keywords

  • Aryl hydrocarbon receptor
  • Correlation
  • Cytotoxicity
  • Endotoxin
  • In vitro
  • In vivo
  • Inflammation
  • Particulate matter

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Toxicology
  • Health, Toxicology and Mutagenesis

Cite this

Breznan, D., Karthikeyan, S., Phaneuf, M., Kumarathasan, P., Cakmak, S., Denison, M. S., ... Vincent, R. (2016). Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter. Particle and Fibre Toxicology, 13(1), [41]. https://doi.org/10.1186/S12989-016-0152-6

Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter. / Breznan, Dalibor; Karthikeyan, Subramanian; Phaneuf, Marcelle; Kumarathasan, Prem; Cakmak, Sabit; Denison, Michael S.; Brook, Jeffrey R.; Vincent, Renaud.

In: Particle and Fibre Toxicology, Vol. 13, No. 1, 41, 2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Breznan, D, Karthikeyan, S, Phaneuf, M, Kumarathasan, P, Cakmak, S, Denison, MS, Brook, JR & Vincent, R 2016, 'Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter', Particle and Fibre Toxicology, vol. 13, no. 1, 41. https://doi.org/10.1186/S12989-016-0152-6
Breznan, Dalibor ; Karthikeyan, Subramanian ; Phaneuf, Marcelle ; Kumarathasan, Prem ; Cakmak, Sabit ; Denison, Michael S. ; Brook, Jeffrey R. ; Vincent, Renaud. / Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter. In: Particle and Fibre Toxicology. 2016 ; Vol. 13, No. 1.
@article{58d207b0b61142998e7591ed42c54b1a,
title = "Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter",
abstract = "Background: Association of particulate matter with adverse health effects has been established in epidemiological studies and animal experiments. Epidemiological studies are difficult to undertake while animal studies are impractical for high-throughput toxicity testing. The ease and rapidity of in vitro tests emphasizes their potential for use in risk assessment of chemicals and particles. We examined the association between in vitro and in vivo responses to ambient particles, to determine the potential of cell-based assays as standalone toxicity screening tools. Methods: Assays of cytotoxicity and key inflammatory mediators were applied to determine the in vitro biological potency of a panel of urban and mineral particles in J774A.1 macrophages and A549 lung epithelial cells. The particles were also screened for the presence of AhR agonists using the Ah receptor-dependent gene induction assay and for endotoxin using the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay. A subset of the particles with a contrasting in vitro toxicity profile was delivered intratracheally in BALB/c mice to assess their in vivo biological potency. Results from various bioassays were combined within the in vitro and in vivo models. The combined potency measures were examined for associations. Results: Overall, J774A.1 cells were more sensitive to particle effects than A549 cells. Whereas the combined cytotoxicity estimates were highly correlated between the two cell lines, the combined in vitro inflammatory potency estimates were not, emphasizing functional differences of the two cell types. Secretion of inflammatory markers by J774A.1 cells was correlated with AhR ligand binding profile and endotoxin levels of particles. Particle instillation led to an acute toxicity response in BALB/c mice, with neutrophilia and release of inflammatory mediators. While the combined toxicity estimates were not correlated between in vitro and in vivo models, the combined inflammatory and integrated potency estimates (toxicity and inflammation) approached the threshold for significance (p = 0.052) in a correlation within in vitro and in vivo models, with a ranking of fine particle (DWR1), minerals (TiO2, CRI) and coarse particles (SRM-, EHC-type) from low to high potency. Conclusion: Integration of in vitro endpoints shows promise in determining adverse outcomes of particle exposures in vivo. The devised data reduction and computational approach will prove useful in the development of models for assessment of hazard potential of particles; however, distinct models may be needed for particles of different type, such as urban particles vs. mineral particles, nanomaterials.",
keywords = "Aryl hydrocarbon receptor, Correlation, Cytotoxicity, Endotoxin, In vitro, In vivo, Inflammation, Particulate matter",
author = "Dalibor Breznan and Subramanian Karthikeyan and Marcelle Phaneuf and Prem Kumarathasan and Sabit Cakmak and Denison, {Michael S.} and Brook, {Jeffrey R.} and Renaud Vincent",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1186/S12989-016-0152-6",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
journal = "Particle and Fibre Toxicology",
issn = "1743-8977",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Development of an integrated approach for comparison of in vitro and in vivo responses to particulate matter

AU - Breznan, Dalibor

AU - Karthikeyan, Subramanian

AU - Phaneuf, Marcelle

AU - Kumarathasan, Prem

AU - Cakmak, Sabit

AU - Denison, Michael S.

AU - Brook, Jeffrey R.

AU - Vincent, Renaud

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Background: Association of particulate matter with adverse health effects has been established in epidemiological studies and animal experiments. Epidemiological studies are difficult to undertake while animal studies are impractical for high-throughput toxicity testing. The ease and rapidity of in vitro tests emphasizes their potential for use in risk assessment of chemicals and particles. We examined the association between in vitro and in vivo responses to ambient particles, to determine the potential of cell-based assays as standalone toxicity screening tools. Methods: Assays of cytotoxicity and key inflammatory mediators were applied to determine the in vitro biological potency of a panel of urban and mineral particles in J774A.1 macrophages and A549 lung epithelial cells. The particles were also screened for the presence of AhR agonists using the Ah receptor-dependent gene induction assay and for endotoxin using the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay. A subset of the particles with a contrasting in vitro toxicity profile was delivered intratracheally in BALB/c mice to assess their in vivo biological potency. Results from various bioassays were combined within the in vitro and in vivo models. The combined potency measures were examined for associations. Results: Overall, J774A.1 cells were more sensitive to particle effects than A549 cells. Whereas the combined cytotoxicity estimates were highly correlated between the two cell lines, the combined in vitro inflammatory potency estimates were not, emphasizing functional differences of the two cell types. Secretion of inflammatory markers by J774A.1 cells was correlated with AhR ligand binding profile and endotoxin levels of particles. Particle instillation led to an acute toxicity response in BALB/c mice, with neutrophilia and release of inflammatory mediators. While the combined toxicity estimates were not correlated between in vitro and in vivo models, the combined inflammatory and integrated potency estimates (toxicity and inflammation) approached the threshold for significance (p = 0.052) in a correlation within in vitro and in vivo models, with a ranking of fine particle (DWR1), minerals (TiO2, CRI) and coarse particles (SRM-, EHC-type) from low to high potency. Conclusion: Integration of in vitro endpoints shows promise in determining adverse outcomes of particle exposures in vivo. The devised data reduction and computational approach will prove useful in the development of models for assessment of hazard potential of particles; however, distinct models may be needed for particles of different type, such as urban particles vs. mineral particles, nanomaterials.

AB - Background: Association of particulate matter with adverse health effects has been established in epidemiological studies and animal experiments. Epidemiological studies are difficult to undertake while animal studies are impractical for high-throughput toxicity testing. The ease and rapidity of in vitro tests emphasizes their potential for use in risk assessment of chemicals and particles. We examined the association between in vitro and in vivo responses to ambient particles, to determine the potential of cell-based assays as standalone toxicity screening tools. Methods: Assays of cytotoxicity and key inflammatory mediators were applied to determine the in vitro biological potency of a panel of urban and mineral particles in J774A.1 macrophages and A549 lung epithelial cells. The particles were also screened for the presence of AhR agonists using the Ah receptor-dependent gene induction assay and for endotoxin using the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay. A subset of the particles with a contrasting in vitro toxicity profile was delivered intratracheally in BALB/c mice to assess their in vivo biological potency. Results from various bioassays were combined within the in vitro and in vivo models. The combined potency measures were examined for associations. Results: Overall, J774A.1 cells were more sensitive to particle effects than A549 cells. Whereas the combined cytotoxicity estimates were highly correlated between the two cell lines, the combined in vitro inflammatory potency estimates were not, emphasizing functional differences of the two cell types. Secretion of inflammatory markers by J774A.1 cells was correlated with AhR ligand binding profile and endotoxin levels of particles. Particle instillation led to an acute toxicity response in BALB/c mice, with neutrophilia and release of inflammatory mediators. While the combined toxicity estimates were not correlated between in vitro and in vivo models, the combined inflammatory and integrated potency estimates (toxicity and inflammation) approached the threshold for significance (p = 0.052) in a correlation within in vitro and in vivo models, with a ranking of fine particle (DWR1), minerals (TiO2, CRI) and coarse particles (SRM-, EHC-type) from low to high potency. Conclusion: Integration of in vitro endpoints shows promise in determining adverse outcomes of particle exposures in vivo. The devised data reduction and computational approach will prove useful in the development of models for assessment of hazard potential of particles; however, distinct models may be needed for particles of different type, such as urban particles vs. mineral particles, nanomaterials.

KW - Aryl hydrocarbon receptor

KW - Correlation

KW - Cytotoxicity

KW - Endotoxin

KW - In vitro

KW - In vivo

KW - Inflammation

KW - Particulate matter

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85007504242&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85007504242&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/S12989-016-0152-6

DO - 10.1186/S12989-016-0152-6

M3 - Article

C2 - 27520027

AN - SCOPUS:85007504242

VL - 13

JO - Particle and Fibre Toxicology

JF - Particle and Fibre Toxicology

SN - 1743-8977

IS - 1

M1 - 41

ER -