Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce: Lessons learned from interviews with medical students

Alexander R. Green, Elizabeth Miller, Edward Krupat, Augustus White, William C. Taylor, David A. Hirsh, Rebbecca P. Wilson, Joseph R. Betancourt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) use standardized patients (SPs) to teach and evaluate medical students' skills. Few studies describe using OSCEs for cultural competence education, now a Liaison Committee on Medical Education accreditation standard for medical schools. We designed an OSCE station emphasizing cross-cultural communication skills (ccOSCE) and interviewed students to better understand and improve upon this tool. Method: Two investigators conducted semistructured interviews with 22 second-year Harvard medical students who completed the ccOSCE. Three investigators coded and analyzed the interview transcripts by using qualitative methods to explore students' perspectives on the station and its focus on cultural competence. Results: Themes that emerged pertinent to design and implementation of the station were grouped into four categories: learning goals, logistical issues, faculty feedback, and SPs. Students were positive about the overall experience. They appreciated the practical focus on nonadherence. Some found the learning goals complex, and others felt the format promoted stereotypes. Logistical issues included concerns about marginalizing cross-cultural care by creating a separate station. Faculty feedback was helpful when specific about sociocultural issues students did or did not explore well. Students found SPs realistic but inconsistent in how easily they revealed information. Conclusion: Designing a ccOSCE experience is challenging but feasible. Students' perspectives highlight a tension between presenting cultural competence in a dedicated station (potentially marginalizing the topic and promoting stereotypes) and spreading it across stations (limiting opportunity for focused teaching). Learning goals should be clear, concise, and effectively communicated to faculty and SPs so their feedback can be standardized and specific.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)344-350
Number of pages7
JournalEthnicity and Disease
Volume17
Issue number2
StatePublished - Mar 2007

Fingerprint

Cultural Competency
Medical Students
Interviews
Students
Learning
Research Personnel
Accreditation
Medical Education
Medical Schools
Teaching
Communication
Education

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Green, A. R., Miller, E., Krupat, E., White, A., Taylor, W. C., Hirsh, D. A., ... Betancourt, J. R. (2007). Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce: Lessons learned from interviews with medical students. Ethnicity and Disease, 17(2), 344-350.

Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce : Lessons learned from interviews with medical students. / Green, Alexander R.; Miller, Elizabeth; Krupat, Edward; White, Augustus; Taylor, William C.; Hirsh, David A.; Wilson, Rebbecca P.; Betancourt, Joseph R.

In: Ethnicity and Disease, Vol. 17, No. 2, 03.2007, p. 344-350.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Green, AR, Miller, E, Krupat, E, White, A, Taylor, WC, Hirsh, DA, Wilson, RP & Betancourt, JR 2007, 'Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce: Lessons learned from interviews with medical students', Ethnicity and Disease, vol. 17, no. 2, pp. 344-350.
Green AR, Miller E, Krupat E, White A, Taylor WC, Hirsh DA et al. Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce: Lessons learned from interviews with medical students. Ethnicity and Disease. 2007 Mar;17(2):344-350.
Green, Alexander R. ; Miller, Elizabeth ; Krupat, Edward ; White, Augustus ; Taylor, William C. ; Hirsh, David A. ; Wilson, Rebbecca P. ; Betancourt, Joseph R. / Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce : Lessons learned from interviews with medical students. In: Ethnicity and Disease. 2007 ; Vol. 17, No. 2. pp. 344-350.
@article{c384ea097146493284dbd56347f7897c,
title = "Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce: Lessons learned from interviews with medical students",
abstract = "Purpose: Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) use standardized patients (SPs) to teach and evaluate medical students' skills. Few studies describe using OSCEs for cultural competence education, now a Liaison Committee on Medical Education accreditation standard for medical schools. We designed an OSCE station emphasizing cross-cultural communication skills (ccOSCE) and interviewed students to better understand and improve upon this tool. Method: Two investigators conducted semistructured interviews with 22 second-year Harvard medical students who completed the ccOSCE. Three investigators coded and analyzed the interview transcripts by using qualitative methods to explore students' perspectives on the station and its focus on cultural competence. Results: Themes that emerged pertinent to design and implementation of the station were grouped into four categories: learning goals, logistical issues, faculty feedback, and SPs. Students were positive about the overall experience. They appreciated the practical focus on nonadherence. Some found the learning goals complex, and others felt the format promoted stereotypes. Logistical issues included concerns about marginalizing cross-cultural care by creating a separate station. Faculty feedback was helpful when specific about sociocultural issues students did or did not explore well. Students found SPs realistic but inconsistent in how easily they revealed information. Conclusion: Designing a ccOSCE experience is challenging but feasible. Students' perspectives highlight a tension between presenting cultural competence in a dedicated station (potentially marginalizing the topic and promoting stereotypes) and spreading it across stations (limiting opportunity for focused teaching). Learning goals should be clear, concise, and effectively communicated to faculty and SPs so their feedback can be standardized and specific.",
author = "Green, {Alexander R.} and Elizabeth Miller and Edward Krupat and Augustus White and Taylor, {William C.} and Hirsh, {David A.} and Wilson, {Rebbecca P.} and Betancourt, {Joseph R.}",
year = "2007",
month = "3",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "17",
pages = "344--350",
journal = "Ethnicity and Disease",
issn = "1049-510X",
publisher = "ISHIB",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Designing and implementing a cultural competence osce

T2 - Lessons learned from interviews with medical students

AU - Green, Alexander R.

AU - Miller, Elizabeth

AU - Krupat, Edward

AU - White, Augustus

AU - Taylor, William C.

AU - Hirsh, David A.

AU - Wilson, Rebbecca P.

AU - Betancourt, Joseph R.

PY - 2007/3

Y1 - 2007/3

N2 - Purpose: Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) use standardized patients (SPs) to teach and evaluate medical students' skills. Few studies describe using OSCEs for cultural competence education, now a Liaison Committee on Medical Education accreditation standard for medical schools. We designed an OSCE station emphasizing cross-cultural communication skills (ccOSCE) and interviewed students to better understand and improve upon this tool. Method: Two investigators conducted semistructured interviews with 22 second-year Harvard medical students who completed the ccOSCE. Three investigators coded and analyzed the interview transcripts by using qualitative methods to explore students' perspectives on the station and its focus on cultural competence. Results: Themes that emerged pertinent to design and implementation of the station were grouped into four categories: learning goals, logistical issues, faculty feedback, and SPs. Students were positive about the overall experience. They appreciated the practical focus on nonadherence. Some found the learning goals complex, and others felt the format promoted stereotypes. Logistical issues included concerns about marginalizing cross-cultural care by creating a separate station. Faculty feedback was helpful when specific about sociocultural issues students did or did not explore well. Students found SPs realistic but inconsistent in how easily they revealed information. Conclusion: Designing a ccOSCE experience is challenging but feasible. Students' perspectives highlight a tension between presenting cultural competence in a dedicated station (potentially marginalizing the topic and promoting stereotypes) and spreading it across stations (limiting opportunity for focused teaching). Learning goals should be clear, concise, and effectively communicated to faculty and SPs so their feedback can be standardized and specific.

AB - Purpose: Objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs) use standardized patients (SPs) to teach and evaluate medical students' skills. Few studies describe using OSCEs for cultural competence education, now a Liaison Committee on Medical Education accreditation standard for medical schools. We designed an OSCE station emphasizing cross-cultural communication skills (ccOSCE) and interviewed students to better understand and improve upon this tool. Method: Two investigators conducted semistructured interviews with 22 second-year Harvard medical students who completed the ccOSCE. Three investigators coded and analyzed the interview transcripts by using qualitative methods to explore students' perspectives on the station and its focus on cultural competence. Results: Themes that emerged pertinent to design and implementation of the station were grouped into four categories: learning goals, logistical issues, faculty feedback, and SPs. Students were positive about the overall experience. They appreciated the practical focus on nonadherence. Some found the learning goals complex, and others felt the format promoted stereotypes. Logistical issues included concerns about marginalizing cross-cultural care by creating a separate station. Faculty feedback was helpful when specific about sociocultural issues students did or did not explore well. Students found SPs realistic but inconsistent in how easily they revealed information. Conclusion: Designing a ccOSCE experience is challenging but feasible. Students' perspectives highlight a tension between presenting cultural competence in a dedicated station (potentially marginalizing the topic and promoting stereotypes) and spreading it across stations (limiting opportunity for focused teaching). Learning goals should be clear, concise, and effectively communicated to faculty and SPs so their feedback can be standardized and specific.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34447512949&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34447512949&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 17682369

AN - SCOPUS:34447512949

VL - 17

SP - 344

EP - 350

JO - Ethnicity and Disease

JF - Ethnicity and Disease

SN - 1049-510X

IS - 2

ER -