Comparison of radiosurgery planning modalities for acoustic neuroma with regard to conformity and mean target dose

Julian R Perks, K. El-Hamri, T. P D Blackburn, P. N. Plowman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: To evaluate dose conformity and mean target dose in light of previous comparative studies and state-of-the-art radiosurgery delivery modalities. Materials and Methods: Seven patients with acoustic neuromas deemed clinically suitable for linear accelerator or Gamma Knife radiosurgery were planned such that the minimum doses for any plan were equal. Gamma Knife plans were prepared in three ways: by altering the prescription of previously published data, by hand and with the assistance of an automatic planning algorithm (wizard). The linear accelerator plans were prepared utilizing a micro-multileaf collimator in both static and dynamic modes. The dose volume histogram analyses lead to a measure of conformity and the mean and minimum target dose for each plan. Statistical significance was calculated as each planning modality was compared with every other. Results: All Gamma Knife plans demonstrated a statistically significantly better conformity when compared with fixed field linear accelerator techniques. When compared to linear accelerator techniques the wizard-assisted Gamma Knife plans demonstrated significantly better conformity. The mean target dose for all the Gamma Knife plans was significantly higher than that of the linear accelerator plans (19.2 Gy vs. 13.4 Gy). Conclusions: Conformity of the prescription isodose to the target shape is of major importance in radiosurgery. The modalities compared represent commercially available and widely accepted systems. Gamma Knife plans derived using the 'wizard' option and finalized by hand yield the best conformity.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)165-171
Number of pages7
JournalStereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery
Volume83
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2005

Fingerprint

Particle Accelerators
Acoustic Neuroma
Radiosurgery
Prescriptions
Hand

Keywords

  • Acoustic neuroma
  • Gamma knife linear accelerator plan comparison
  • Micro-multileaf collimator

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Neurology

Cite this

Comparison of radiosurgery planning modalities for acoustic neuroma with regard to conformity and mean target dose. / Perks, Julian R; El-Hamri, K.; Blackburn, T. P D; Plowman, P. N.

In: Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery, Vol. 83, No. 4, 12.2005, p. 165-171.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9ec96b45f7254c508771d2c65016cfa9,
title = "Comparison of radiosurgery planning modalities for acoustic neuroma with regard to conformity and mean target dose",
abstract = "Purpose: To evaluate dose conformity and mean target dose in light of previous comparative studies and state-of-the-art radiosurgery delivery modalities. Materials and Methods: Seven patients with acoustic neuromas deemed clinically suitable for linear accelerator or Gamma Knife radiosurgery were planned such that the minimum doses for any plan were equal. Gamma Knife plans were prepared in three ways: by altering the prescription of previously published data, by hand and with the assistance of an automatic planning algorithm (wizard). The linear accelerator plans were prepared utilizing a micro-multileaf collimator in both static and dynamic modes. The dose volume histogram analyses lead to a measure of conformity and the mean and minimum target dose for each plan. Statistical significance was calculated as each planning modality was compared with every other. Results: All Gamma Knife plans demonstrated a statistically significantly better conformity when compared with fixed field linear accelerator techniques. When compared to linear accelerator techniques the wizard-assisted Gamma Knife plans demonstrated significantly better conformity. The mean target dose for all the Gamma Knife plans was significantly higher than that of the linear accelerator plans (19.2 Gy vs. 13.4 Gy). Conclusions: Conformity of the prescription isodose to the target shape is of major importance in radiosurgery. The modalities compared represent commercially available and widely accepted systems. Gamma Knife plans derived using the 'wizard' option and finalized by hand yield the best conformity.",
keywords = "Acoustic neuroma, Gamma knife linear accelerator plan comparison, Micro-multileaf collimator",
author = "Perks, {Julian R} and K. El-Hamri and Blackburn, {T. P D} and Plowman, {P. N.}",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1159/000089987",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "83",
pages = "165--171",
journal = "Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery",
issn = "1011-6125",
publisher = "S. Karger AG",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of radiosurgery planning modalities for acoustic neuroma with regard to conformity and mean target dose

AU - Perks, Julian R

AU - El-Hamri, K.

AU - Blackburn, T. P D

AU - Plowman, P. N.

PY - 2005/12

Y1 - 2005/12

N2 - Purpose: To evaluate dose conformity and mean target dose in light of previous comparative studies and state-of-the-art radiosurgery delivery modalities. Materials and Methods: Seven patients with acoustic neuromas deemed clinically suitable for linear accelerator or Gamma Knife radiosurgery were planned such that the minimum doses for any plan were equal. Gamma Knife plans were prepared in three ways: by altering the prescription of previously published data, by hand and with the assistance of an automatic planning algorithm (wizard). The linear accelerator plans were prepared utilizing a micro-multileaf collimator in both static and dynamic modes. The dose volume histogram analyses lead to a measure of conformity and the mean and minimum target dose for each plan. Statistical significance was calculated as each planning modality was compared with every other. Results: All Gamma Knife plans demonstrated a statistically significantly better conformity when compared with fixed field linear accelerator techniques. When compared to linear accelerator techniques the wizard-assisted Gamma Knife plans demonstrated significantly better conformity. The mean target dose for all the Gamma Knife plans was significantly higher than that of the linear accelerator plans (19.2 Gy vs. 13.4 Gy). Conclusions: Conformity of the prescription isodose to the target shape is of major importance in radiosurgery. The modalities compared represent commercially available and widely accepted systems. Gamma Knife plans derived using the 'wizard' option and finalized by hand yield the best conformity.

AB - Purpose: To evaluate dose conformity and mean target dose in light of previous comparative studies and state-of-the-art radiosurgery delivery modalities. Materials and Methods: Seven patients with acoustic neuromas deemed clinically suitable for linear accelerator or Gamma Knife radiosurgery were planned such that the minimum doses for any plan were equal. Gamma Knife plans were prepared in three ways: by altering the prescription of previously published data, by hand and with the assistance of an automatic planning algorithm (wizard). The linear accelerator plans were prepared utilizing a micro-multileaf collimator in both static and dynamic modes. The dose volume histogram analyses lead to a measure of conformity and the mean and minimum target dose for each plan. Statistical significance was calculated as each planning modality was compared with every other. Results: All Gamma Knife plans demonstrated a statistically significantly better conformity when compared with fixed field linear accelerator techniques. When compared to linear accelerator techniques the wizard-assisted Gamma Knife plans demonstrated significantly better conformity. The mean target dose for all the Gamma Knife plans was significantly higher than that of the linear accelerator plans (19.2 Gy vs. 13.4 Gy). Conclusions: Conformity of the prescription isodose to the target shape is of major importance in radiosurgery. The modalities compared represent commercially available and widely accepted systems. Gamma Knife plans derived using the 'wizard' option and finalized by hand yield the best conformity.

KW - Acoustic neuroma

KW - Gamma knife linear accelerator plan comparison

KW - Micro-multileaf collimator

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=29144471202&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=29144471202&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1159/000089987

DO - 10.1159/000089987

M3 - Article

C2 - 16319520

AN - SCOPUS:29144471202

VL - 83

SP - 165

EP - 171

JO - Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery

JF - Stereotactic and Functional Neurosurgery

SN - 1011-6125

IS - 4

ER -