Comparison of insertion time and pullout strength between self-tapping and non-self-tapping AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone

C. Renee Andrea, Susan M Stover, Larry D Galuppo, Ken T. Taylor, Peter C. Rakestraw

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective - To compare screw insertion characteristics and pullout mechanical properties between self-tapping (ST) and non-self-tapping (NST) AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone (MC3). Study Design - In vitro biomechanical experiment. Animals or Sample Population - Seven pairs of adult equine MC3. Methods - Bicortical holes were drilled transversely in proximal metaphyseal, diaphyseal, and distal metaphyseal locations of paired MC3. NST screws were inserted in pre-tapped holes in 3 sites of one bone pair, and ST screws were inserted in non-tapped holes of contralateral MC3. Tapping and screw insertion times and maximum torques were measured. Screw pullout mechanical properties were determined. Results - Screw insertion time was longer for ST screws. Total time for tapping and insertion (total insertion time) was over twice as long for NST screws. Statistically significant differences were not observed between screws for any pullout mechanical property. From pullout tests, diaphyseal locations had significantly stiffer and stronger structure than metaphyseal locations. Pullout failure more commonly occurred because of screw breakage than bone failure. Bone failure and bone comminution were more commonly associated with ST screws. Bone failure sites had pullout failure loads that were 90% of screw failure sites. Conclusions - NST and ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws have similar pullout mechanical properties from adult equine MC3. ST screws require less than half the total insertion time of NST screws. Clinical Relevance - Use of ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws should be considered for repair of adult equine MC3 fractures; however, bone failures at screw sites should be monitored.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)189-194
Number of pages6
JournalVeterinary Surgery
Volume31
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 2002

Fingerprint

Bone Screws
metacarpus
Metacarpal Bones
screws
strength (mechanics)
Horses
bones
horses
Bone and Bones
Torque
mechanical properties
Cortical Bone
Population

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • veterinary(all)

Cite this

Comparison of insertion time and pullout strength between self-tapping and non-self-tapping AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone. / Andrea, C. Renee; Stover, Susan M; Galuppo, Larry D; Taylor, Ken T.; Rakestraw, Peter C.

In: Veterinary Surgery, Vol. 31, No. 3, 05.2002, p. 189-194.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{1708486468674fff9bba7e0427f248d3,
title = "Comparison of insertion time and pullout strength between self-tapping and non-self-tapping AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone",
abstract = "Objective - To compare screw insertion characteristics and pullout mechanical properties between self-tapping (ST) and non-self-tapping (NST) AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone (MC3). Study Design - In vitro biomechanical experiment. Animals or Sample Population - Seven pairs of adult equine MC3. Methods - Bicortical holes were drilled transversely in proximal metaphyseal, diaphyseal, and distal metaphyseal locations of paired MC3. NST screws were inserted in pre-tapped holes in 3 sites of one bone pair, and ST screws were inserted in non-tapped holes of contralateral MC3. Tapping and screw insertion times and maximum torques were measured. Screw pullout mechanical properties were determined. Results - Screw insertion time was longer for ST screws. Total time for tapping and insertion (total insertion time) was over twice as long for NST screws. Statistically significant differences were not observed between screws for any pullout mechanical property. From pullout tests, diaphyseal locations had significantly stiffer and stronger structure than metaphyseal locations. Pullout failure more commonly occurred because of screw breakage than bone failure. Bone failure and bone comminution were more commonly associated with ST screws. Bone failure sites had pullout failure loads that were 90{\%} of screw failure sites. Conclusions - NST and ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws have similar pullout mechanical properties from adult equine MC3. ST screws require less than half the total insertion time of NST screws. Clinical Relevance - Use of ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws should be considered for repair of adult equine MC3 fractures; however, bone failures at screw sites should be monitored.",
author = "Andrea, {C. Renee} and Stover, {Susan M} and Galuppo, {Larry D} and Taylor, {Ken T.} and Rakestraw, {Peter C.}",
year = "2002",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1053/jvet.2002.32398",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "31",
pages = "189--194",
journal = "Veterinary Surgery",
issn = "0161-3499",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of insertion time and pullout strength between self-tapping and non-self-tapping AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone

AU - Andrea, C. Renee

AU - Stover, Susan M

AU - Galuppo, Larry D

AU - Taylor, Ken T.

AU - Rakestraw, Peter C.

PY - 2002/5

Y1 - 2002/5

N2 - Objective - To compare screw insertion characteristics and pullout mechanical properties between self-tapping (ST) and non-self-tapping (NST) AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone (MC3). Study Design - In vitro biomechanical experiment. Animals or Sample Population - Seven pairs of adult equine MC3. Methods - Bicortical holes were drilled transversely in proximal metaphyseal, diaphyseal, and distal metaphyseal locations of paired MC3. NST screws were inserted in pre-tapped holes in 3 sites of one bone pair, and ST screws were inserted in non-tapped holes of contralateral MC3. Tapping and screw insertion times and maximum torques were measured. Screw pullout mechanical properties were determined. Results - Screw insertion time was longer for ST screws. Total time for tapping and insertion (total insertion time) was over twice as long for NST screws. Statistically significant differences were not observed between screws for any pullout mechanical property. From pullout tests, diaphyseal locations had significantly stiffer and stronger structure than metaphyseal locations. Pullout failure more commonly occurred because of screw breakage than bone failure. Bone failure and bone comminution were more commonly associated with ST screws. Bone failure sites had pullout failure loads that were 90% of screw failure sites. Conclusions - NST and ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws have similar pullout mechanical properties from adult equine MC3. ST screws require less than half the total insertion time of NST screws. Clinical Relevance - Use of ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws should be considered for repair of adult equine MC3 fractures; however, bone failures at screw sites should be monitored.

AB - Objective - To compare screw insertion characteristics and pullout mechanical properties between self-tapping (ST) and non-self-tapping (NST) AO 4.5-mm cortical bone screws in adult equine third metacarpal bone (MC3). Study Design - In vitro biomechanical experiment. Animals or Sample Population - Seven pairs of adult equine MC3. Methods - Bicortical holes were drilled transversely in proximal metaphyseal, diaphyseal, and distal metaphyseal locations of paired MC3. NST screws were inserted in pre-tapped holes in 3 sites of one bone pair, and ST screws were inserted in non-tapped holes of contralateral MC3. Tapping and screw insertion times and maximum torques were measured. Screw pullout mechanical properties were determined. Results - Screw insertion time was longer for ST screws. Total time for tapping and insertion (total insertion time) was over twice as long for NST screws. Statistically significant differences were not observed between screws for any pullout mechanical property. From pullout tests, diaphyseal locations had significantly stiffer and stronger structure than metaphyseal locations. Pullout failure more commonly occurred because of screw breakage than bone failure. Bone failure and bone comminution were more commonly associated with ST screws. Bone failure sites had pullout failure loads that were 90% of screw failure sites. Conclusions - NST and ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws have similar pullout mechanical properties from adult equine MC3. ST screws require less than half the total insertion time of NST screws. Clinical Relevance - Use of ST 4.5-mm-diameter cortical bone screws should be considered for repair of adult equine MC3 fractures; however, bone failures at screw sites should be monitored.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0036582619&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0036582619&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1053/jvet.2002.32398

DO - 10.1053/jvet.2002.32398

M3 - Article

C2 - 11994845

AN - SCOPUS:0036582619

VL - 31

SP - 189

EP - 194

JO - Veterinary Surgery

JF - Veterinary Surgery

SN - 0161-3499

IS - 3

ER -