Comparison of indirect video laryngoscopes in children younger than two years of age: A randomized trainee evaluation study

Marissa Vadi, Elizabeth A. Ghazal, Bryan Halverson, Richard Lee Applegate

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Gaining proficiency with various airway management tools is an important goal for anesthesiology training. Indirect video laryngoscopes facilitate tracheal intubation in adults, but it is not clear whether these findings translate to children. This study evaluates the total time to successful intubation when performed by anesthesiology trainees using GlideScope Cobalt® video laryngoscopy (GlideScope), Storz DCI® video laryngoscopy (Storz), or direct laryngoscopy (Direct) in children <2 years old with normal airway anatomy. Methods: Sixty-five children presenting for elective surgery were randomly assigned to undergo tracheal intubation using GlideScope, Storz, or Direct. Laryngoscopists were anesthesiology trainees in clinical anesthesia year ≥2 who had proven basic proficiency with each laryngoscope on an infant airway manikin. Total time to successful intubation (TTSI, seconds), rate of successful intubation on first laryngoscopy attempt, and the change in intubation time from manikin to clinical settings were recorded. An intubation time difference >10 seconds was defined as clinically significant. Results: TTSI was longer for Storz (42.1; 34.0 to 59.0) than for Direct (21.5; 17.0 to 34.3; p=0.002). We were not able to demonstrate a difference >10 seconds between the GlideScope and the other laryngoscopes. Median manikin intubation time was <10 seconds and increased significantly in the clinical setting for all laryngoscopes (all p <0.0001). Conclusions: Anesthesiology trainees completed manikin tracheal intubation rapidly with all laryngoscopes studied, but required a clinically significant longer time to tracheally intubate children <2 years. Our findings suggest in vivo training should be included to facilitate proficiency with device-specific intubation techniques.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)401-410
Number of pages10
JournalMiddle East Journal of Anesthesiology
Volume23
Issue number4
StatePublished - Feb 1 2016
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Laryngoscopes
Intubation
Laryngoscopy
Anesthesiology
Manikins
Airway Management
Cobalt
Equipment and Supplies

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)
  • Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine

Cite this

Comparison of indirect video laryngoscopes in children younger than two years of age : A randomized trainee evaluation study. / Vadi, Marissa; Ghazal, Elizabeth A.; Halverson, Bryan; Applegate, Richard Lee.

In: Middle East Journal of Anesthesiology, Vol. 23, No. 4, 01.02.2016, p. 401-410.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{cadf5b2ad7b14786a829b04bb6e6b0d4,
title = "Comparison of indirect video laryngoscopes in children younger than two years of age: A randomized trainee evaluation study",
abstract = "Background: Gaining proficiency with various airway management tools is an important goal for anesthesiology training. Indirect video laryngoscopes facilitate tracheal intubation in adults, but it is not clear whether these findings translate to children. This study evaluates the total time to successful intubation when performed by anesthesiology trainees using GlideScope Cobalt{\circledR} video laryngoscopy (GlideScope), Storz DCI{\circledR} video laryngoscopy (Storz), or direct laryngoscopy (Direct) in children <2 years old with normal airway anatomy. Methods: Sixty-five children presenting for elective surgery were randomly assigned to undergo tracheal intubation using GlideScope, Storz, or Direct. Laryngoscopists were anesthesiology trainees in clinical anesthesia year ≥2 who had proven basic proficiency with each laryngoscope on an infant airway manikin. Total time to successful intubation (TTSI, seconds), rate of successful intubation on first laryngoscopy attempt, and the change in intubation time from manikin to clinical settings were recorded. An intubation time difference >10 seconds was defined as clinically significant. Results: TTSI was longer for Storz (42.1; 34.0 to 59.0) than for Direct (21.5; 17.0 to 34.3; p=0.002). We were not able to demonstrate a difference >10 seconds between the GlideScope and the other laryngoscopes. Median manikin intubation time was <10 seconds and increased significantly in the clinical setting for all laryngoscopes (all p <0.0001). Conclusions: Anesthesiology trainees completed manikin tracheal intubation rapidly with all laryngoscopes studied, but required a clinically significant longer time to tracheally intubate children <2 years. Our findings suggest in vivo training should be included to facilitate proficiency with device-specific intubation techniques.",
author = "Marissa Vadi and Ghazal, {Elizabeth A.} and Bryan Halverson and Applegate, {Richard Lee}",
year = "2016",
month = "2",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "23",
pages = "401--410",
journal = "Middle East Journal of Anesthesiology",
issn = "0544-0440",
publisher = "American University of Beirut",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of indirect video laryngoscopes in children younger than two years of age

T2 - A randomized trainee evaluation study

AU - Vadi, Marissa

AU - Ghazal, Elizabeth A.

AU - Halverson, Bryan

AU - Applegate, Richard Lee

PY - 2016/2/1

Y1 - 2016/2/1

N2 - Background: Gaining proficiency with various airway management tools is an important goal for anesthesiology training. Indirect video laryngoscopes facilitate tracheal intubation in adults, but it is not clear whether these findings translate to children. This study evaluates the total time to successful intubation when performed by anesthesiology trainees using GlideScope Cobalt® video laryngoscopy (GlideScope), Storz DCI® video laryngoscopy (Storz), or direct laryngoscopy (Direct) in children <2 years old with normal airway anatomy. Methods: Sixty-five children presenting for elective surgery were randomly assigned to undergo tracheal intubation using GlideScope, Storz, or Direct. Laryngoscopists were anesthesiology trainees in clinical anesthesia year ≥2 who had proven basic proficiency with each laryngoscope on an infant airway manikin. Total time to successful intubation (TTSI, seconds), rate of successful intubation on first laryngoscopy attempt, and the change in intubation time from manikin to clinical settings were recorded. An intubation time difference >10 seconds was defined as clinically significant. Results: TTSI was longer for Storz (42.1; 34.0 to 59.0) than for Direct (21.5; 17.0 to 34.3; p=0.002). We were not able to demonstrate a difference >10 seconds between the GlideScope and the other laryngoscopes. Median manikin intubation time was <10 seconds and increased significantly in the clinical setting for all laryngoscopes (all p <0.0001). Conclusions: Anesthesiology trainees completed manikin tracheal intubation rapidly with all laryngoscopes studied, but required a clinically significant longer time to tracheally intubate children <2 years. Our findings suggest in vivo training should be included to facilitate proficiency with device-specific intubation techniques.

AB - Background: Gaining proficiency with various airway management tools is an important goal for anesthesiology training. Indirect video laryngoscopes facilitate tracheal intubation in adults, but it is not clear whether these findings translate to children. This study evaluates the total time to successful intubation when performed by anesthesiology trainees using GlideScope Cobalt® video laryngoscopy (GlideScope), Storz DCI® video laryngoscopy (Storz), or direct laryngoscopy (Direct) in children <2 years old with normal airway anatomy. Methods: Sixty-five children presenting for elective surgery were randomly assigned to undergo tracheal intubation using GlideScope, Storz, or Direct. Laryngoscopists were anesthesiology trainees in clinical anesthesia year ≥2 who had proven basic proficiency with each laryngoscope on an infant airway manikin. Total time to successful intubation (TTSI, seconds), rate of successful intubation on first laryngoscopy attempt, and the change in intubation time from manikin to clinical settings were recorded. An intubation time difference >10 seconds was defined as clinically significant. Results: TTSI was longer for Storz (42.1; 34.0 to 59.0) than for Direct (21.5; 17.0 to 34.3; p=0.002). We were not able to demonstrate a difference >10 seconds between the GlideScope and the other laryngoscopes. Median manikin intubation time was <10 seconds and increased significantly in the clinical setting for all laryngoscopes (all p <0.0001). Conclusions: Anesthesiology trainees completed manikin tracheal intubation rapidly with all laryngoscopes studied, but required a clinically significant longer time to tracheally intubate children <2 years. Our findings suggest in vivo training should be included to facilitate proficiency with device-specific intubation techniques.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84956619455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84956619455&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 27382808

AN - SCOPUS:84956619455

VL - 23

SP - 401

EP - 410

JO - Middle East Journal of Anesthesiology

JF - Middle East Journal of Anesthesiology

SN - 0544-0440

IS - 4

ER -