Choosing general surgery

Insights into career choices of current medical students

Dmitri V. Gelfand, Yale D. Podnos, Samuel E. Wilson, Jonathon Cooke, Russell A. Williams, Darryl T. Hiyama, William Schecter, Earl S. Schuman, Julie Freischlag, John Vetto, James E Goodnight Jr, Arthur Stanten, William Plested, Bruce Stabile, Thomas Russell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

102 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Hypothesis: The number of unfilled general surgery programs in the United States increased from 4 in 1999 to 41 in 2001. This study seeks to determine if changes in student attitudes occurring during their medical school careers and during the third-year general surgery clerkship contribute to a decline in interest in a surgical career. Design: Prospective survey of medical students at a public medical school in California. Participants and Methods: Each medical student received a survey via the Internet. Responses were anonymous. Once quantified, X2 analysis was used for comparison and analysis of survey results. Comparisons were made between individual class years and on the basis of whether the respondent completed the third-year general surgery clerkship. Results: Of 368 surveys sent, 232 (63%) were successfully completed and included in the study. Comparison of students' attitudes before and after completion of their general surgery clerkship showed that following surgical course exposure more students believed surgery lacked breadth of expertise, limitations over stress, control over one's time, regularity of schedule, adequacy of leisure time, and income commensurate to workload (P<.05). These results are also consistent in comparisons between individual class years. Conclusions: Data suggest that medical students seem to be more concerned with issues of "controllable lifestyle" such as adequacy of family and/or leisure time, high level of stress, and amount of work and commitment. The erosion of income differential between demanding and less taxing specialties was also an important cause cited for the flagging interest in surgical disciplines.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)941-947
Number of pages7
JournalArchives of Surgery
Volume137
Issue number8
StatePublished - 2002
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Career Choice
Medical Students
Leisure Activities
Students
Medical Schools
Workload
Internet
Life Style
Appointments and Schedules
Surveys and Questionnaires

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Surgery

Cite this

Gelfand, D. V., Podnos, Y. D., Wilson, S. E., Cooke, J., Williams, R. A., Hiyama, D. T., ... Russell, T. (2002). Choosing general surgery: Insights into career choices of current medical students. Archives of Surgery, 137(8), 941-947.

Choosing general surgery : Insights into career choices of current medical students. / Gelfand, Dmitri V.; Podnos, Yale D.; Wilson, Samuel E.; Cooke, Jonathon; Williams, Russell A.; Hiyama, Darryl T.; Schecter, William; Schuman, Earl S.; Freischlag, Julie; Vetto, John; Goodnight Jr, James E; Stanten, Arthur; Plested, William; Stabile, Bruce; Russell, Thomas.

In: Archives of Surgery, Vol. 137, No. 8, 2002, p. 941-947.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gelfand, DV, Podnos, YD, Wilson, SE, Cooke, J, Williams, RA, Hiyama, DT, Schecter, W, Schuman, ES, Freischlag, J, Vetto, J, Goodnight Jr, JE, Stanten, A, Plested, W, Stabile, B & Russell, T 2002, 'Choosing general surgery: Insights into career choices of current medical students', Archives of Surgery, vol. 137, no. 8, pp. 941-947.
Gelfand DV, Podnos YD, Wilson SE, Cooke J, Williams RA, Hiyama DT et al. Choosing general surgery: Insights into career choices of current medical students. Archives of Surgery. 2002;137(8):941-947.
Gelfand, Dmitri V. ; Podnos, Yale D. ; Wilson, Samuel E. ; Cooke, Jonathon ; Williams, Russell A. ; Hiyama, Darryl T. ; Schecter, William ; Schuman, Earl S. ; Freischlag, Julie ; Vetto, John ; Goodnight Jr, James E ; Stanten, Arthur ; Plested, William ; Stabile, Bruce ; Russell, Thomas. / Choosing general surgery : Insights into career choices of current medical students. In: Archives of Surgery. 2002 ; Vol. 137, No. 8. pp. 941-947.
@article{e324f46ba6dd455ca2a605bb38a9535c,
title = "Choosing general surgery: Insights into career choices of current medical students",
abstract = "Hypothesis: The number of unfilled general surgery programs in the United States increased from 4 in 1999 to 41 in 2001. This study seeks to determine if changes in student attitudes occurring during their medical school careers and during the third-year general surgery clerkship contribute to a decline in interest in a surgical career. Design: Prospective survey of medical students at a public medical school in California. Participants and Methods: Each medical student received a survey via the Internet. Responses were anonymous. Once quantified, X2 analysis was used for comparison and analysis of survey results. Comparisons were made between individual class years and on the basis of whether the respondent completed the third-year general surgery clerkship. Results: Of 368 surveys sent, 232 (63{\%}) were successfully completed and included in the study. Comparison of students' attitudes before and after completion of their general surgery clerkship showed that following surgical course exposure more students believed surgery lacked breadth of expertise, limitations over stress, control over one's time, regularity of schedule, adequacy of leisure time, and income commensurate to workload (P<.05). These results are also consistent in comparisons between individual class years. Conclusions: Data suggest that medical students seem to be more concerned with issues of {"}controllable lifestyle{"} such as adequacy of family and/or leisure time, high level of stress, and amount of work and commitment. The erosion of income differential between demanding and less taxing specialties was also an important cause cited for the flagging interest in surgical disciplines.",
author = "Gelfand, {Dmitri V.} and Podnos, {Yale D.} and Wilson, {Samuel E.} and Jonathon Cooke and Williams, {Russell A.} and Hiyama, {Darryl T.} and William Schecter and Schuman, {Earl S.} and Julie Freischlag and John Vetto and {Goodnight Jr}, {James E} and Arthur Stanten and William Plested and Bruce Stabile and Thomas Russell",
year = "2002",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "137",
pages = "941--947",
journal = "JAMA Surgery",
issn = "2168-6254",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Choosing general surgery

T2 - Insights into career choices of current medical students

AU - Gelfand, Dmitri V.

AU - Podnos, Yale D.

AU - Wilson, Samuel E.

AU - Cooke, Jonathon

AU - Williams, Russell A.

AU - Hiyama, Darryl T.

AU - Schecter, William

AU - Schuman, Earl S.

AU - Freischlag, Julie

AU - Vetto, John

AU - Goodnight Jr, James E

AU - Stanten, Arthur

AU - Plested, William

AU - Stabile, Bruce

AU - Russell, Thomas

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - Hypothesis: The number of unfilled general surgery programs in the United States increased from 4 in 1999 to 41 in 2001. This study seeks to determine if changes in student attitudes occurring during their medical school careers and during the third-year general surgery clerkship contribute to a decline in interest in a surgical career. Design: Prospective survey of medical students at a public medical school in California. Participants and Methods: Each medical student received a survey via the Internet. Responses were anonymous. Once quantified, X2 analysis was used for comparison and analysis of survey results. Comparisons were made between individual class years and on the basis of whether the respondent completed the third-year general surgery clerkship. Results: Of 368 surveys sent, 232 (63%) were successfully completed and included in the study. Comparison of students' attitudes before and after completion of their general surgery clerkship showed that following surgical course exposure more students believed surgery lacked breadth of expertise, limitations over stress, control over one's time, regularity of schedule, adequacy of leisure time, and income commensurate to workload (P<.05). These results are also consistent in comparisons between individual class years. Conclusions: Data suggest that medical students seem to be more concerned with issues of "controllable lifestyle" such as adequacy of family and/or leisure time, high level of stress, and amount of work and commitment. The erosion of income differential between demanding and less taxing specialties was also an important cause cited for the flagging interest in surgical disciplines.

AB - Hypothesis: The number of unfilled general surgery programs in the United States increased from 4 in 1999 to 41 in 2001. This study seeks to determine if changes in student attitudes occurring during their medical school careers and during the third-year general surgery clerkship contribute to a decline in interest in a surgical career. Design: Prospective survey of medical students at a public medical school in California. Participants and Methods: Each medical student received a survey via the Internet. Responses were anonymous. Once quantified, X2 analysis was used for comparison and analysis of survey results. Comparisons were made between individual class years and on the basis of whether the respondent completed the third-year general surgery clerkship. Results: Of 368 surveys sent, 232 (63%) were successfully completed and included in the study. Comparison of students' attitudes before and after completion of their general surgery clerkship showed that following surgical course exposure more students believed surgery lacked breadth of expertise, limitations over stress, control over one's time, regularity of schedule, adequacy of leisure time, and income commensurate to workload (P<.05). These results are also consistent in comparisons between individual class years. Conclusions: Data suggest that medical students seem to be more concerned with issues of "controllable lifestyle" such as adequacy of family and/or leisure time, high level of stress, and amount of work and commitment. The erosion of income differential between demanding and less taxing specialties was also an important cause cited for the flagging interest in surgical disciplines.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0036322496&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0036322496&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 137

SP - 941

EP - 947

JO - JAMA Surgery

JF - JAMA Surgery

SN - 2168-6254

IS - 8

ER -